comScore
Uncategorized Monday, March 28th 2011 at 5:46 pm

Depressing: Chinese Vendors Selling Live Fish and Turtles in Plastic Bags as Keychains

Chinese vendors have been selling pretty depressing keychains (two words I never thought I’d hear together) that consist of either a Brazil turtle or two small kingfish sealed inside a small plastic baggy. Each baggy, seven centimeters in length, is filled with colored liquid and the imprisoned animal(s) of choice. The vendors, who sell the baggies at the entrances to subways or train stations, claim the colored water is a “nutrient rich” solution that allows the live creatures shoved inside a seven centimeter bag to live for a few months, after which–if this story couldn’t get any more depressing–the animals die and, according to Helablog, “rumor has it…the cadavers are heated in the microwave for 15 seconds and eaten while enjoying an ice cold beer.”

If the existence of these keychains wasn’t depressing enough, the fact that they’re not illegal makes them even worse, as China only has a Wild Animal Protection Law, under which these keychains do not happen to fall. Since there is no law preventing the existence of these keychains, so there may not be an end to them anytime soon and, according to the Global Times, the depressing keychain business is doing well, as they reportedly watched one fish keychain and nine turtle keychains sell in five minutes time, to both people who think they’re neat, and others who buy the keychains to free the animals.

According to the cofounder of the International Center for Veterinary Services, Mary Peng, the fish and turtles wouldn’t survive too long in the sealed plastic bag due to the lack of oxygen, regardless of how “nutrient rich” the colored water may be. Animal protection groups are voicing their opinion on the matter, so hopefully they can quickly make progress toward getting these keychains made illegal.

(Global Times via Weird Asia News via Helablog)

Filed Under |
  • http://twitter.com/fordies990 Ian Ford

    This is absolutely disgusting!!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000144103361 Abbē Neumann

    This is awful! >:(

  • Cute_megan4u

    I don’t know what to do other than boycott China. Don’t buy their products and don’t spend your vacation dollars there, or any other place that condones such legalized animal torture.

  • Zandali

    Should you wait til it dies to eat it or cook it before that point for freshness

  • http://meatvideo.com Dan M.

    Know what’s even worse? Meatvideo.com

  • http://meatvideo.com Dan M.

    Know what’s even worse? Meatvideo.com

  • Dr Coene

    My first reaction when I read the headline and saw the picture was to cut it open and let the little guy out into a pond. My second reaction was to think “Would he be okay in a pond or would I accidentally just kill him due to not knowing anything about this breed of turtle?” And my third reaction was “Is this even a turtle, or is this a tortoise? Wait, what’s the difference between a turtle and a tortoise to begin with? Why don’t I know the difference between a turtle and a tortoise? I’m 26 years old, I should know these things. If a little six year old kid comes up to me and asks me what the difference between a turtle and tortoise is I’m not going to have any idea what to say. I suppose I could lie to him, or her, but that’s only going to lead to some awkward moments for him, or her, in the future with school teachers, or even a job opportunity far into their adulthood. A reputable business CEO is going to offhandedly mention something about a tortoise and he, or she, is going to incorrectly correct them by telling them the difference I explained to him, or her, between a turtle and a tortoise which isn’t actually true. That’s not a good way to begin a business relationship. The only option would be to tell the truth, which is that I don’t know the difference between a turtle and a tortoise is because I did a lot of drugs in high school and never payed attention in class and that he, or she, should use me as an example of why he, or she, should never, ever, EVER do drugs, because then one day a six year old kid will ask you what the difference between a turtle and a tortoise is and you’ll have only two options, one being to lie to them, and the other being to explain to them that you did a lot of drugs in high school and never paid attention in class and that he, or she, should use you as an example of why he, or she, should never, EVER do drugs.”

  • No

    What a load of crap. How do they breathe for “several months”? The oxygen would run out within minutes. Get a life people.

  • Dr Coene

    Yeah! Get a life, people who don’t understand things!

  • Oni

    It would take a day or 3 before a shallow breather like a turtle and one that small to boot , to run out of air

  • Senor Chang

    Really. Fighting ignorance with ignorance… good luck with that.

  • Neo92631043

    My only question is: where can I buy one? Cause I gotta do it quick, this article keeps talkIng about them being banned. I NEED ME A TURTLE KEYCHAIN!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1845341141 Joe Otley

    I just made a post about this myself. You can buy these everywhere here in Guangzhou. In the mall, in the park, at the zoo, at the pet market. Check out my photos of the horrendous pet market in GZ: http://guangjoe.tumblr.com/post/4000712831/huadiwan-pet-market-guangzhou

  • http://twitter.com/OhMyClarence J. Clarence

    This is really depressing, and it goes to show how apathetic some humans can be to non-human life. Setting aside the issue of making living creatures key chain ornaments, would it really have been cost prohibitive to make the punch holes in the sack for the little guy to breathe through? Also, who buys this and doesn’t realize quickly that there is no way for oxygen to get then, and the whole thing is just an ornamental death trap.

    We can shrug this off as just another weird thing the people in the East do, but I was at a harbor in Connecticut where I saw live lobsters in a tank used as the little plush toys in those claw machine games, where if you actually managed to grab a lobster and drop it through the hole, you would win a free lobster. Though a different lobster, because they one you caught is destroyed because it isn’t fit for eating.

  • Leachshaun

    I used to work in a pet pet shop! when we sold fish filled with water and air (atleast 1/2 a bag of air to water) the fish would actually use up all that oxygen within 1/2 hour to an hour!? so i would think that the air in these sealed bags would not last that long !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Debbie

    It’s not funny, you stupid prick!

  • Bobbybrown

    my first reaction was, Would they then turn into teeanage mutants?

  • Boner

    well, for dipshits like him it is :(

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1478316231 Sheerikhawo Banaktsang

    Does China do anything good at all????

  • jibwire

    of course they do, just like most other countries. but they do a lot of shit as well, just like any other country.

  • http://twitter.com/drunkenbozo drunkenbozo

    i would buy them all

    then set them free :)

  • Azza89

    and by buying them ur givign them profits. and we all know profits are an incentive to do a certain action. so by byiing to free them, all ur doing is trapping more. idiots. its like chrisitan organisations buying slaves in africa to free them. a lot of the time the freed slaves are caught again. so ur channeling money from good uses adn giving it to gangs and warlords. brilliant

  • Casmith

    These don’t even make good keychains.

  • Abbypoo

    You’re a stupid shit. I hope they put assholes like you in 7cm plastic bags.

  • Banana

    hahaha, I want one of them too! plus, if I ever get hungry, it’s free turtle food! YAY!!

  • Julie Smith7

    sick and twisted :(

  • Awsedjyh

    “Ignorance with ignorance?” How moronic. A boycott is far from ignorance. If China doesn’t like a boycott, maybe it will change its laws.

  • Asmhd

    ADD perhaps?

  • Asmhd

    I literally want to throw up after reading this. And then, people here make jokes when they cannot handle the seriousness of something like animal cruelty. That’s just closing your eyes to and sidestepping a real issue. Make jokes about funny things, not animals who are in tremendous pain because they cannot breath in a plastic bag.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1426329824 Jeff Bassett

    I want one so bad! They’re adorable!! & it’s like popcorn when it dies! Microwaveable bag & everything!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=638894014 Caleb Sierp

    To everyone saying how awful this is… I assume you’re retards that don’t consider how this life ‘keychain life’ is nothing compared to the life of a 90% of meat-producing chickens in the States… Beaks cut off and force-fed corn until their body weight breaks their legs.
    But you don’t think about that when you’re eating your KFC or eating that “healthy” chicken salad from McDonald’s.
    Just because you don’t see it, you put it out of your mind.
    Fuck you, hypocrites.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Maria-Tang/100000978756734 Maria Tang

    I think that, if the baggie on the key chain could actually OPEN, then it wouldn’t be so much of a problem, because then you can take the pet out to feed it, and give it some fresh air and much needed exercise. It shouldn’t be so hard to invent such kind of baggies, you know.
    However, right now, it is unnecessarily cruel, because these animals die pointlessly.

  • Gary

    To reiterate what Caleb said above:

    This is such a horrible display of human negligence and I have no idea how these things even start or why China has no laws against domestic animal abuse. However we can also look at factory farming here in North America and Europe, where the treatment of animals includes physical confinement to the point of widespread osteoporosis, debeaking of chickens at birth and force feeding to the point of their legs breaking under their own weight, mass drugging, uncontrolled exposure to disease, genetic mutation, and viruses from being left in their own waste for months at a time. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factory_farming) We are all complacent in these processes as the consumers and we act on some and turn a blind eye to others. I don’t think humans will ever really understand each other or be justified in the things we do

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_662P4RLSSVRVTI7XWZIRJPJ5JM Art Vandelay

    once the keychains are made illegal, it will draw more attention for idiots to them…hopefully, the fad runs its course and becomes very unpopular.

  • Ophidic

    Yeah I don’t see how boycotting this is ignorant. I’m pretty fed up with china what with all their lead paint and human rights violations and their lopsided gender balance due to horrific acts justified by antiquated ideas, but this takes the goddamned fucking cake!

  • StrayWolfZ

    Honestly to think boycotting a country that produces an almost unfathomable amount of products sold in the US, not only by chinese corporations, but US outsourced corporations, IS INDEED extremely ignorant. How about actually taking a stand against the atrocity itself? Doing something DIRECTLY instead of indirectly. You’re not boycotting a small ma & pa shop here…

  • Ophidic

    Yeah I don’t live in china… that makes it a little hard to be direct.

  • Sha Shou

    well… if they only used this for use of travel (temporary) it’d be fine!
    of course transfer it back into its tank or something…
    but if i wanted to bring my turtle to school; i’d use a larger version of this or something?
    don’t keep it in there; put it back in a water tank or something better

  • Dick

    Logical fallacy. Try again.

  • Stargaze83

    Not to mention… getting shaken to death, getting crushed underneath things, inside purses, whatever. A soft bag offers no protection. So horrible.

  • Atmd

    Maybe I’m wrong, but the only disgusting person in this is the person who buys this and lets the animal die inside.
    The fact is that no one would sel these unless people paid money to buy them. The act of selling them isnt cruel, only buying them to let the animals die.

    People give away goldfish in bags at fairgrounds? no real difference in the delivery, only the way the purchaser (or should that be perchasee) uses them

  • BoyCott China

    You and your country sucks. I for one will start today by boycotting your hideous place you call your mother country. Wish only the chinese ppl would suffer the same faith they have reserved for these defenseless creatures. Boo! to you, may a tsunami kill you all!

  • angrywhitegirl

    Seriously, how are you actually going to boycott China?
    Have you seen China? It’s pretty big. China also has some weird thing with being economical strategic, smart and owning almost 40% of the world’s exporting systems.
    Furthermore the population of some several billion pouring money into the economy – ironically and horribly by buying these said keychains – will really make a one man, or even a 1000 man boycott of China and it’s products somewhat unimportant. It’s like you stating to boycott all processed foods because of how they are made – good luck with that one.

    So technically, its not ignorant. It’s stupid. China doesn’t care about baby turtles and goldfish – and given their previous history of war, not giving a f**k and communism, I think it’s pretty safe to say that some angry forum readers deciding to boycott China (all living in an presumably first world country with a large important business, McDonalds, foreign cars and other plastics) is not going to make a huge world wide difference.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_Z4CJFSWSF6NJQ2QO56FEBHKHJM K

    Here are the problems with your post:
    1) You are assuming everyone eats meat. Some people don’t. With the knowledge humans have now about nutrition it is possible to lead a completely meat-free life.
    2) You are assuming those who eat meat always get it through acts of cruelty. There are ways of killing animals to make sure they suffer as briefly as possible and some people are sure to do this.
    3) You are comparing the killing of animals for FOOD – something which is natural – with the imprisonment of animals in plastic bags for novelty? Really?

  • Maggie

    Take it out and exercise it? it shouldn’t be in there in the first place!

  • Ricardoredline

    chinese stupidity has no limits

  • Ricardoredline

    a new idea, put a chinese inside one of those bags… just for good luck!

  • Abc

    Some Chinese are sick people..

  • anon

    apparently ignorance has no limits as well.

  • Miss_londonuk

    For that motherfucking prick up there who sed a ‘tsunami shud hit china’….are you fuckin dumb?? just because a proportion of dese chinese people sell it, does it mean you should degrade everyone who is chinese??!?! for example jus becos muslims hit the twin towers 9/11…yer those fuckers should die, but it doesnt mean you shud genralise all muslims to be like that! think before you speak u twat!!!!!! i bet half the people who are cussing these chinese people either eat chinese food or own clothes which are made in china!!!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1548955144 Nicole Paetow

    THIS CRAP NEED’S TO BE STOPPED NOW !!!!. THIS IS WRONG AND CRUEL !!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1548955144 Nicole Paetow

    THIS CRAP NEED’S TO BE STOPPED NOW !!!!. THIS IS WRONG AND CRUEL !!!

  • http://twitter.com/VampFaerie Nicole Countryman

    This is Cruel beyond words! It needs to be stopped and banned!

  • Turtle!

    I would never buy more than one, but I honestly think that I would actually buy one of these.. Just to be able to say “Hey.. did you know that at one point in my life I had a little turtle on a keychain?..”

  • nerdherd

    Why would you ever wish for a natural disaster to happen? Your immaturity, ignorance, and racism makes me sick.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1427581095 Gerri Higa

    I agree with you! We should be appalled at the action not a WHOLE NATION of people. That’s just crazy! Not all Chinese find this act okay so why punish them too. We seem to be blaming a whole nation for the actions of a few. I sure don’t want to be blamed for actions the US does that I don’t agree with. Concentrate your anger where it would do some good. Help to educate and make changes in laws, build awareness and remember that all people are not the same.

  • http://twitter.com/Kim_Garza Kim Garza

    This is absolutely wrong, & disgusting. Perhaps we should sell these Chinese people in plastic bags to suffocate & sell them as keychains? Then let’s see how fast this shit will end.

  • http://profiles.google.com/jenniferlynnadams Jennifer Adams

    People laugh because this is the kind of shit you just can’t make up.

  • Miss_londonuk

    Why dont you just shut up you dumb bitch! yeah what they are doing is definently wrong, im not denying that, but is there any need for that kind of talk?!?!?! Not all chinese people agree with this u know!!!!

  • Breannagwynn

    :( I want to buy one to rescue it! <3 :( I wish I could but them all so I can rescue them all! Or steal them so I wouldnt have to pay for such cruelty.

  • http://twitter.com/Meli_0876 Melissa Hutter

    This is why I would NEVER visit your country. You are disgusting and cruel to animals. Is that really what you teach your children? To be unhearted and vicious? What you don’t have anything better to do with your time than to sit there and ABUSE animals!!!! I have not been so disgusted with in my life than to hear or see of these horrible things that you people are doing to animals. I would buy all those poor turtles and whatever else you are hurting just to set them free. They are suffocating!!!!!

  • http://twitter.com/SmackithTheDown Cody Lambert

    I like turtle soup…

  • Ghostadvnturesgirly

    OMG this is the most sick thing i have ever seen in my life and anyone who like this should be out into one of those bags and die!

  • Debbie

    You do no better by calling someone a mother fucking prick and a twat…..Can you not speak to someone in a civil tone with out being angry? to tell that person that you disagree with them…..there is no need for the hateful remarks it will only be met back with more hateful remarks….speak your mind yes but don’t lower yourself to be the same as the one you speak your mind to.

  • Debbie

    Actions of a Few?? Really?? you need to check into the background a little more before you make that statement.

  • Debbie

    I agree Nicole……most definitely agree. People find it funny and or cute….wonder how those people that condone these actions would like it if they were captured and put in a plastic bag with nutrient rich water as they say which is a total lie and then sealed and left to die…They treat animals this way there not to far way from treating humans that way as well. People on this earth take everything for granted and have no care or concern for anything but there self. That’s truly sad, and people wonder why the world is in the shape it is?? Seriously People take your head out of the sand and look around you at what is happening and instead of constantly running your mouth bitching about everything…..Stand up and be counted….call it as you see it…..go out there and try to make a real difference you might be surprised at how well you do and or you may be that one person who will stop at nothing to prevent things like the keychains from happening…you never know until you try. Thats the problem with alot of people though these days. They simply don’t want to put the effort into actually trying to make something happen but yet they can run there mouth constantly on the problems but never bother trying to make a real difference…..Why shouldn’t you do that?? It’s your planet, your life, does that not count for anything?? I think it does and before you say it I have done things to make a difference in my life time.

  • Debbie

    Your just a barrel of sunshine aren’t you?? you really need to learn how to talk to people you seem to have a real anger issue in just simply trying to reply to people…..and you can come back and run your mouth all you want at my comment LOL it won’t bother me…..so have at it but I will not lower myself to your standards and respond.

  • Harumihale

    racist.

  • Harumihale

    Of course I, for one, would be angry if someone was being a racist. Although her language is a bit crude, I agree wholeheartedly that not all Chinese people do this kind of stuff. :

    She doesn’t have anger issues, but she definitely knows how to call out someone on their racism.

  • Harumihale

    Not all Chinese people are cruel to animals. You’re generalizing an entire nation and its people. How would you feel if I starting stereotyping you? And my parents teach me to be kind and respectful, not a racist bigot like you. :)

    P.S. What exactly is unhearted?

  • Tkdchick11

    Wow, does anyone understand what could possibly happen by boycotting China? Not only would you hurt the country itself, but it would also affect America seeing as they are one of our biggest trading partners. Now, do you think America, at this point in time, is in the business of making MORE people/countries mad? I don’t think so. By cutting of trade, making China “bummed out” would be the worst of our problems. You cannot blame the producer for making something that consumers will buy. Would you blame hershey for making you fat? Absolutely not, or you should’nt at least. I agree 100% that these keychains go beyond the realm of “wrong” or “inhumane”, but its not chinas fault, its the person who is making them who should suffer the consequences. Besides, even suggesting the idea of boycotting China is ridiculous. Do you seriously think boycotting China, of ALL places, would ever happen? Come on now, folks, get real.

  • Tkdchick11

    HAHAHA wow, are you kidding me? Is this your way of expressing concern? Go back to 1st grade dude, even they will think this comment is immature and IGNORANT, just like the suggestion of “boycotting” china. What a joke.

  • Tkdchick11

    You’re right but at the same time, the chickens that are being tortured are actually USED for something, not to stick on your keychain to make a good conversation piece. Absolutely how they handle chickens is wrong, and I wish I could do something to change that, but these chickens are killed to be consumed by humans, which is their purpose. There is a difference between the two.

  • Tkdhick11

    HAHAHAHA wow, thats like saying to jews during the holocaust “We’re going to put you in a concentration camp and torture you until you wish you were dead..but we offer free meals.” Seriously? Seriously?

  • Pokerchamp69

    Save the turtles and fish destroy a country. Makes a lot of since.
    You are the reason people are so depressed with this country.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001120392392 Bethany Stewart

    Ok yes I agree this is inhumane and disgusting. Yea I’d buy them to release them but as someone noted, I’d be giving them money to make more. Though I don’t understand how us signing petitions and such to make China stop is gonna help. Our jurisdiction doesn’t fly over there now if this starts happening in the US then yea petition away.

  • creeper

    Its really an amazing thing that people who are supposedly the epitome of super intelligence lack the most simple values of life. Super Intelligence is nothing without the balance of compassion and understanding. Instead of parading around, claiming to be the top notch of brainiac society, maybe they need to invest a little more time into finding something with true purpose and meaning. Apparently their 10, 12, 24 hour school days amount to jack shit in the way of moral values. Then again, they are just as comfortable sitting down and frying up your family dog.. so I guess it really isnt that far of a stretch. I say burn their flags, seal em in bags.

  • http://twitter.com/Meli_0876 Melissa Hutter

    Well, whoever is doing that to the animals is WHO I was talking to. I don’t want to go to a place and see that. Don’t go jumping at me!!!!

  • Miss_londonuk

    Wow!!!! All the racists are starting to come out on this page!!!! I wonder if everyone is this open about their racism in public, or is it just over the internet they do this??? People really need to go back to school and be educated about stereotyping people…and for all you people who are sittin there saying how ‘a tsunami shud hit china’ and that ‘chinese people shud be put in plastic bags’???????? U need to THINK before you SPEAK!!!!! Yes this is wrong, BUT why are you degrading the whole of china?!?!?! Not every single chinese person agrees with this!!!! And as for ‘Debbie’ or whatever your name is….You dont know me, so dont even think about tellin me how i got ‘anger issues’….its not called anger issues love get it right!!, its called speaking out against racism and showing these dimwits how pathetic their comments are!!!!!!!

  • quote-me

    Well, that’s just not fathomable. I’m assuming he’s an average sized human being, possibly between 5 and 6 feet, with the exception of him being a little person, to which it would still be ridiculously difficult to pack him into a 7cm plastic bag. You could try, but it would probably rip before even a foot was crammed into it.

  • GACFAN&LOVER

    i agree with your answer :)

  • Melanie Tilbrook

    I totally agree with you Abbypoo maybe gods Kharma would be to put all these people in plastic bags, sadly for us I think God has more compassion than them, after all 2 wrongs don’t make a right.
    I don’t know what makes me more sick the fact that people would do this to turtles or the fact that on lookers think it’s funny and don’t want to save that poor thing.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Roland-W-Rivard/629793578 Roland W Rivard

    every country has there bad people and canada is no different then any other country other then the usa if there is any country to boycott it’s them not china

  • Courtney

    Ohhmg.. this made me cry! I can’t even imagine this… this is just horrible and sick. I hate people. What’s wrong with the world, honestly.

  • Tita_soendoro

    This is very Inhuman, heartless…how could someone do something like that ?
    I hope the Chinese government do something to stop this cruelness………

  • Aayushi

    LOL

  • Coolprincess29

    i’ll buy tht!

  • Kim Gold

    I agree this is disgusting.

    But while we blame other, do we not eat meat? We accused them of killing the turtles and fish, while we eat fish and chips?

    The keychains sale need to be stop, but for people that are scolding up there, you guys are murderer too. Just because they are FOOD, doesn’t justify what you do is correct!

  • g09483yg3490g93040

    What a bunch of assholes.

  • Dachinez

    i think its pretty cool…

  • Adrian_qx

    dude we cant boycott Chinese products everything is made there im sure if u turn ur keyboard and mouse and check ur monitor and PC there from there not to mention ur clothes and shoes, even the placards that u will use to hold a boycott demo will be made in china just as they make the “free tibet” postcards

  • Cécile from Belgium

    That’s DISGUSTING !! Turtles and fishes are living creatures, not accessories…

  • http://expressmasti.blogspot.com/2011/04/live-fish-and-turtles-sold-as-keychains.html Tania Mirza

    breaking the animal law in china….

  • http://www.facebook.com/rawaussieathlete Grant Campbell

    Boycotting an entire country is like rejecting your best friend because they are friends with someone you don’t like.
    Control is a form of disconnection. It weakens relationships.
    We need to strengthen relationships to enrich the quality of life.
    As vegans we naturally avoid many unethical products.
    A boycott is unnurturing. China, and the rest of us included, needs all the nurturing we can get to leave behind the destructive “us” and “them” mentality.
    People will only see the futility of focusing on material possessions (and treating life as commodities) when they realize we are gifted all of the ingredients for nirvana at birth.

  • Nfohnfonf

    chinky fucks!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1427581095 Gerri Higa

    I was under the assumption that we were talking about this one issue. Based on the population of China and the people involved with this matter then yes it is just a few. I can’t believe that all the people of China was involved in this matter. If they had said, “more than half of the Chinese people accept the keychains” Then my statement would’ve said something different. I stand by what I said, you can’t blame a whole nation for the actions of a few.

  • danfree

    who in their right minds would do something so horribly to these little creatures. To have to live like this and die a miserable death is just sad and not necessary.

  • http://www.facebook.com/MelissaLRobertson Melissa Robertson-Noriega

    I’m sorry to sound racist, but Asians don’t seem to have a whole lot of regard for life. They’re raised (in some places) to eat puppies so they’re probably pretty desensitized to all animal cruelty. They eat EVERYTHING it seems, so it’s just like us Americans having little to no regard for the poor animals we eat.

  • Zhou

    Hey, just because a few retards in China are doing this doesn’t mean you American people can get all racist on us Chinese people. I’m Chinese and I do not condone this act. Eff off, racists.

  • Sefgdfg

    this makes me not proud of being chinese

  • Ashleybauche

    WTF what is wrong with people! If I could I’d buy them all and set the animals free.

  • Lol

    I’m sorry to sound racist, but Americans don’t seem to have a whole lot of knowledge of foreigners. They’re raised (in some places) to think that Asians eat puppies so they’re probably pretty desensitized to all Asian animal cruelty. They’ll believe ANYTHING they read it seems.

  • Disgusted

    Oh my god. You are brilliant. And yes, Melissa is, wow, pretty darn racist. Not only are people vile to animals, they’re also vile to each other. Lovely world we live in.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1493666214 Anonymous

    I am just finding it hard to be upset about this. Lets face it, this is china, and these critters were destined to become someone’s snack. To die in a plastic bag from lack of oxygen is no worse than being cooked or chopped up alive. It seems strange to want to carry them around in a key chain, but it seems less cruel than the way we farm animals to eat in North America.

  • TurtleLOVER

    Can you buy these online? My daughter’s birthday is coming up and she just loves turtles!! :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/sornptar JBee Keller

    This really is beyond disgusting. I try to keep an open mind to other cultures and the differences between my own, but this is simply fvcked in all kinds of ways.

  • http://twitter.com/perception88 Isabella West

    The depravity of the human race never ceases to shock me. This is barbaric anyone involved in this trade is a monster!

  • http://www.facebook.com/ajkidd Drew Kidd

    Tiny animal keychains? That’s god-awful.

    Now if they were USB flash drives, I might have a change of heart.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1371608167 Brian Beacom

    FYI Tortoises are primarily land dwellers whereas Turtles are sea-farers.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1371608167 Brian Beacom

    she said plastic bagS plural, we’ll just carve them into pieces and stick each piece into a bag, the problem there of course is with that they don’t actually get to live for somewhere between 3 days and several months in someones pocket with rapidly depleting oxygen, perhaps we parade them around our cities in glass boxes until they are nearly dead then carve them up starting with limbs and non-major arteries…. yess this should do

  • Miss London UK

    Ok so for all you retards who keep saying ‘ALL chinese people are disgusting’..how bout u cut the crap n stop streotyping people!!!

    lets put this into context shall we??
    most white people smoke crack – does dis mean ALL white people are crackheads???
    most black people go out to rob people n go round killing each other – does dis mean ALL black people do this??
    most asian people carry out terrorist attacks – does dis mean they are ALL terrorists!

    ….WELL THEN! shutup u ignorant people!

    and if theres anyone who hasnt seen jamie olivers cooking programs, i suggest u look it up on youtube!! he slaughters pigs n rabbits live on camera jus to make a meal…so ur tellin me that aint worse then this?

  • Anonymous

    Keyrings, you should see what they can put in a Keycase.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1371608167 Brian Beacom

    unfortunately its sealed, yes you can cut them open and release the animal but that’s clearly not the intent

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1371608167 Brian Beacom

    Lets chill for a second – most people aren’t saying “ALL chinese people are disgusting” yes there are a minority that do and that’s unfortunate however I find it a bit hypocritical to denounce people for stereotyping and then make the statements you followed with “most white people smoke crack”, “most black people go out to rob people n go round killing each other”, “most asian people carry out terrorist attacks” – can I see some research validating these frankly offensive claims against ethnicity’s? Just because you say most and not all doesn’t make it any better.

    As per your comment about Jamie Oliver, had you bothered to pay attention to the program rather than rant about it – Jamie Oliver is a strong advocate and infact actively campaigns for fairer systems for the killing of animals – yes as a chef he is clearly for the killing of animals for food but outside of those campaign efforts he does it in the best possible way for the animal to cause it least suffering – when campaigning he will show the way it is done by the food industry in an attempt to shock viewers into doing something about the horrific treatment some animals under go.

    I hope I have shifted your viewpoint slightly and you can watch Jamie Oliver in a new light now. :-)

  • http://www.facebook.com/ajkidd Drew Kidd

    Jamie Oliver killing rabbits and pigs on camera is not worse than this because they are tasty. If you think that’s brutal, you may as well sell your soul to PETA and start living an unsustainable and expensive lifestyle shunning all animal products.

  • Miss London UK

    YEP! Exactly what i thought!!! you people dont like it when the tables are turned do you?!? you weeny people always find a way to defend your own race!!! :) It’s cool though, HYPORCRITES! and to dat airhead up there ‘brian beacon’!!! Are you stupid as well as a retard? you said im saying ‘offensive claims’ how do you think all these chinese people feel when you’re all stereotyping them on here??? and as for those comments I made about other races, I was givin you idiots a dose of your own medicine!!! it’s not good to be stereotyped IS IT?!!?!? DATS WHAT I WAS TRYIN TO SAY!!! NOT ALL PEOPLE ARE LIKE THIS!!!! and as for ‘drew kidd’ your just stupid!!! ‘its not worse because they are tasty’?? what the fuck? stupid peope!

  • Manna_q

    They dont care a flyin fig if someone or something dies just so they can get a few more dollars. Look these up:
    - babies being aborted and sold to make soup (apparently to make their skin beautiful, youthful essence anyone?)
    - beat up bears until they produce enough hormone and take their bile for ‘medicinal purposes’
    - paint their pork dark to make it look like beef
    - use charcoal to color the rice black to make it seem like the expensive kind
    - ‘recycle’ unsold moncake even if it is 2 yrs old. Cut them up, take out the yellow egg yolks, crush em and mix with a sticky oil paste to form like new. Oh and they do the same with bread too. And it’s not like the pudding your grandma used to make
    - and the piece d’ resistance—-tainted powder milk! Guess where the protein nutients come from….recyled leather!!!! Generously provided by the landfill or you friendly neighborhood shoe making supplier. And to think that it’s their future generation who’s drinking it! Any they, what, are ordered only one child per household? And if they’re die or become cripplingly ill because of this????

    I forgot, they make you pay mandatory ‘fee’ of no lower than $200 that doesnt include the gifts, to attend as a guest at a wedding feast. Did i mention that its’s per person?

    All done by the very same people who look down on poor people who dont own/ wear a branded item, cannot go out without anything expensive on their body, drive an inexpensive car—-anything that has to do with high price tag!

    We can call them Super! Superficial, super stupid and stuper cruel!

  • eya

    WHY???!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1371608167 Brian Beacom

    airhead.. burn

    Anyhoo we’ll push right on ignoring the fact you can’t spell my name and tackle your counter-arguments, though I say counter-arguments you don’t refute the fact you’ve made racist remarks towards almost every general population group in existence, merely claiming that it is in some way okay because I made remarks about Chinese, which lets face it is pretty idiotic in itself but lets just hold up one second because you see you’re doing it AGAIN, or rather not doing it, where “it” is reading before you open your mouth, in fact if you had read my earlier comments in not one did I mention or insinuate any distaste towards the Chinese, nor infact the people perpetuating this act of animal cruelty my only comment on this article was regarding the people making jokes about how they supported the actions of a minority group of Chinese citizens and finally just to close you re-affirm my point that your belief of stereotyping is to say all people invoke a certain characteristic, as long as you say most that’s totally fine.

    Though I will certainly agree with you that Drew’s comment didn’t exactly epitomise the peak of human intellect.

  • Urban_Drum

    Eating chickens isn’t necessary. You eat chickens because you enjoy doing so… people buy these keychains because the enjoy them. I know people don’t buy turtle keychains because they want to be part of an evil plan… they buy them because they enjoy them and they don’t know better… just like meat eaters. That’s my opinion… now, do what makes you happy with it (enjoy it or attack it)… I LOVE ALL OF YOU!

  • Angelaguthery

    You can guarantee as soon as someone writes or says something like “not to sound racist” they’re going to say or write something entirely idiotic after. Case in point ^^^^^^

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lynn-Waddell/100001500167489 Lynn Waddell

    I’m not asian or american but I have seen the cruelty on live dog and cat markets in Asia, where dogs are skinned alive, dogs are beaten to death in the belief that pain tenderises the meat, and cats thrown alive into boiling water, happy to post a link if you would like to see for yourself.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lynn-Waddell/100001500167489 Lynn Waddell

    Not all Chinese people are animal abusers, many Chinese people are fighting hard for animal welfare laws, campaigning against bear farming, and joining the growing network of animal charities across China and Asia.

  • Nickarson

    post a link

  • Deliverme82

    Probably there a pack of ASS HOLES dude.

  • Babes5573

    Zandell. What a worthless piece of dog shit you are. Why dont you do the world a favour a slice yourself up Sociopath. This world has enough of tasteless, worthless ass wipes like you. No wants you around on the planet I can assure you.

  • Sarah Ann ;)

    This is sick, disgusting, and distasteful. I just want to go buy them all up and set them all free !!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=669551267 Sarah Rowland

    Let’s bag THEM up, and sell THEM as boat anchors. Now THERE’S an idea !! Haha.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=669551267 Sarah Rowland

    Please do not send a link ! I believe you. It is horrible, especially with the sea life that is washing up dead from the massive oil spill. These poor sea souls just can’t catch a break !

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=669551267 Sarah Rowland

    Please do not send a link ! I believe you. It is horrible, especially with the sea life that is washing up dead from the massive oil spill. These poor sea souls just can’t catch a break !

  • PETAheater

    FUDGE!!!! Where can I buy these, that is sooooo coooolllll…….. Love it!

  • PETAheater

    FUDGE!!!! Where can I buy these, that is sooooo coooolllll…….. Love it!

  • Anonymous

    Or any adjective: Hey, I don’t wanna sound like a queer or nothin’, but I think unicorns are kick ass! – Dave the Lighting Guy, Orgazmo

  • Anonymous

    “You cannot blame the producer for making something that consumers will buy.”
    That’s crap logic. Replace keychain with mail order bride, for example.

    And for argument’s sake, I believe I could absolutely boycott everything from China if I wanted or needed to. It might hurt Walmart but over the longer term, retailers in the US would start stocking US made goods and Americans might actually find some jobs again.

  • Anonymous

    “You cannot blame the producer for making something that consumers will buy.”
    That’s crap logic. Replace keychain with mail order bride, for example.

    And for argument’s sake, I believe I could absolutely boycott everything from China if I wanted or needed to. It might hurt Walmart but over the longer term, retailers in the US would start stocking US made goods and Americans might actually find some jobs again.

  • Tkdhick11

    Thats crap logic? How so? I absolutely agree that what these people are doing is wrong but what about the people who are actually buying it? Can you blame the people who are selling them if they are obviously making a profit? I bet you 87% of this earths population would continue making their much needed profit even if it was morally wrong. There are so many examples of companies out there who, sure are at fault for selling something that isn’t “healthy” or in “good” taste, but people buy it all. the. time. Mcdonalds? KEY example. I think everyone including mcdonalds CEO can agree that their food falls WAYY under the umbrella of unhealthy, but can you blame them for selling it? Absolutely not. Obviously the mcdonalds is surviving in America’s harsh economy and why is that? Because people buy it. Mcdonalds would be a fool to shut down business because their calorie count exceeds our national debt. So when obese Americans or whoever in the world start filing lawsuits against mcdonalds because they made them fat…well, they are an idiot. Did mcdonalds drive you to their restaurant everyday and fill you up with a carbonated beverage and grease every monday night? No honey, you did. Its not Mcdonalds fault. These key chain people are doing the same thing…making business that, sure may be wrong, but its obviously a booming industry that many people want and have no problem paying for.

    HA ok, go ahead and look underneath EVERY item you own, I bet 90% of it has been made in china. Think its so easy to boycott America NUMBER ONE trade partner? Do it. Don’t you think that if this is what would be best for America right now, we would be doing it? I can assure you that anyone who brought up the idea of boycotting china in congress would be laughed at, harshly. And it wouldn’t just hurt Walmart, it would hurt everybody, everything, our economy that already sucks. But hey, you think its so easy, go ahead and try “boycotting” china. Haha, good luck.

  • http://twitter.com/My_Song_Bird mylittlesongbird.com

    What a Joke shame on the freaks who thought of this Dumb design and SHAME on the idiots who buy these little critters to wear or carry around for them to perish in the sun we here in Australia set these type of little turtles up in aquariums with fresh water and plants I think that is bad enough they belong in the wild

  • Creatureifgod2003

    Other countries do eat dog,where have you been?!

  • Creatureifgod2003

    Other countries do eat dog,where have you been?!

  • ▲↓

    Not trying to say that this isn’t horrible, but there are such worse things being done to HUMANS, RIGHT NOW this very second, Why does crap like this make headlines?

  • Knife

    wow… a lot of people really read this website huh?

  • Knife

    wow… a lot of people really read this website huh?

  • stupidamerican

    Your right, many (not all, not even the majority of) Americans dont seem to have a whole lot of knowledge of foreigners. These atrocities happen everywhere and are caused by sick people regardless of nationality. Lets not forget about Michael Vick and his disgusting actions, but he is a good football player so its OK. Dog fights, cock fights, dolphins and whales being killed, these morons putting turtles in plastic bags. Every race has these F’d up people that have no regard for life. Lets call these people what they are and not preface them with where there from.

  • Las7983

    I’d want to buy them all just to free them but I wouldn’t want to support those people and have them sell more. I’d be so torn on what to do…

  • Yuhwhut

    Worse than being put in a space hardly bigger than yourself and slowly suffocating? I’m sure there are plenty of awful things we are capable of but that’s pretty high up the list.

    ‘Crap’ like this makes headlines cos some of us are capable of feeling compassion for humans AND other species.

  • Tammy

    First off – I believe all living things deserve to be treated with respect… I am aware of HOW GREATLY we (the human race) fall short (across the globe, in many areas). We as a people (doesn’t matter where we are born or what we look like, we are all people) need to work together. Education is the key to promote positive change. How about focusing on – “What can we do to change public opinion about the desire for this type of product?”. Just my two cents…

  • http://www.facebook.com/syrenje Sara Johnston

    Senor Chang has a point, actually. Animal cruelty like this and more — and a video I’ve just watched of a woman eating a live fish after being deep-fried — is NOT merely isolated in China, for example. In Mexico, they breed and eat dogs. I’m serious. Africa — most of the time they don’t end the life of their kill immediately after a hunt; and even some twisted idiots in America, too.

    Things of this nature are NOT isolated in China, and I wish people would realise this. Yes, it comes out with probably the most outlandish ways to animal curelty, such as these keychains, but they’re certainly not the only ones. Open your eyes.

  • http://www.facebook.com/syrenje Sara Johnston

    Senor Chang has a point, actually. Animal cruelty like this and more — and a video I’ve just watched of a woman eating a live fish after being deep-fried — is NOT merely isolated in China, for example. In Mexico, they breed and eat dogs. I’m serious. Africa — most of the time they don’t end the life of their kill immediately after a hunt; and even some twisted idiots in America, too.

    Things of this nature are NOT isolated in China, and I wish people would realise this. Yes, it comes out with probably the most outlandish ways to animal curelty, such as these keychains, but they’re certainly not the only ones. Open your eyes.

  • Sduhfd

    You’re a fucking idiot.

  • Jim

    it’s sick, but i still want one…

  • Carebear9882

    I would buy one, bring it home and out it in my fish tank =) It’s much bigger and the turtle could become my new best friend !

  • http://profiles.google.com/neeraj.designs Neeraj Bhatt

    Very bad

  • sylvie spazz

    that’s extremely racist of you to say. thats like saying all americans are fat or all blondes are stupid.
    i agree that this “animal keychain” is disgusting though

  • sylvie spazz

    that’s extremely racist of you to say. thats like saying all americans are fat or all blondes are stupid.
    i agree that this “animal keychain” is disgusting though

  • Cccuti1999

    u very racist. Yes, bagging animals is wrong but really? I am chinese and im against it!  

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Elementalist-Chee/100000880190025 Elementalist Chee

    so cruel, don’t buy !!!

  • Clialialia

    what about u americans? there’s a lot of cows, chickens, pigs being ill-treated! they are all animals too, why u see it differently then?

  • Anonymous

    uhmmm food is food melissa… you eat poor little chickens and cows and lil bo peeps sheep not only do you eat them by the boat load you torture them prior to culling

  • Anonymous

    when you’re poor and struggling to put any semblance of food on the table keeping a marine animal in a bag as a pet to sell to teenagers and foreigners isn’t an issue all… after all the purchaser is responsible for removing the pet from the bag… have you never purchased fish for your fish tank? (dont they come in a bag too and sometimes die b4 you get home?)

  • Ncaradonna214193

    These were two dollars each..(the turtles anyway) so I Bought about 20 of them. When I got home I released them from their plastic prisons and released them into my pond where they now live. They grew like crazy. They’re almost double the size from when I bought them.

  • Kerrisue23

    It’s really quite simple. You put any animal in a plastic bag with no air, ot’ll die. Any idiot knows that. That’s what makes it disgusting.

  • IGotThePooOnMe

    Kosher cows are forced into a thing that holds thier head and thier neck is slit by a rabbi and it bleeds to death….thats pretty fucked up I think but people buy that b.s. anyways.

  • http://twitter.com/Candarian_Demon Harry Palma

    FUCKING GOOKS!

  • F-22

    Wow I’m Canadian and you guys need to chill. As well please stop putting Animals in tinny bags. I’m a vet as well and it is considered to be animal cruelty

  • Nitramsjesska

    post a link!!

  • Jasan

    not all asian ! Just this China People!!!!!! Shame on china people!

  • Seriously….get a life

    Wah Wah Wah……

  • Suckmyballs

    yea but you’re still eating a nice steak for dinner and a nice chicken salad for lunch, just because you’re talking about animals we love as pets here in the west doesn’t make it any different to killing any animal for food, and before you ask yes i,m a meet eater myself

  • Bob

    They do that with non-kosher too but they restrain and stun the cow then hang them upside down first. This way they don’t fight and the blood drains from the carotid and jugular faster. Sounds better right? Well, the captive bolt pistol used to “stun” usually either kills or mortally injures before they make it to the line. Bleed to death or be bludgeoned and the bleed. Not very good choices, just very good steaks.

  • Fadd

    Just nuke them they are a abomination.

  • Kevindbales

    Different cultures have different values.
    This is an obvious, provable truth.
    You can be uncomfortable with the fact that some value human life more than others or that some value turtle life more than others. 
    Education, personal industry, honesty; these are all subjective values.
    There are still whole nations where the old people disrespect young people who focus on education when they should be out trying to have sex with all the other young people. 
    There are still whole nations where people who do not steal are though of as fools by everyone around them.
    There are still whole nations where a young man who does not rape is though of as weak.

    And, worst of all, there are subcultures within the “modern” world where all these things are true.

  • Markrahman69

    Bastards… Seal the people who selll these things head in a plastik bag add some color water to it and see them suffocating slowly …

  • Supraboii

    You people are idiots.. you guys believe everything and anything you read.. this is exactly why America is being flushed down the toilets..   dumb rocks..

  • BBGunlover

    I don’t give a crap about stupid ass animals. 

  • Iam That Mother Fucker

    Common sense isn’t very common any more. People just have no damn mind. Plus, this is all for money. They’re greedy and could care less about the animals, obviously. It’s just like murder. Mass murder. They should be put in the electric chair. Fucking idiots.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000753358013 Reuben Higgins

    OMG I WANT ONE, Then I’d set them all free in my fish tank

  • Uransakura

    I totally disagree about ppl here making comments on all Asian eat dogs. Not every places in the world are as developed as America where we have abundance of resources and food, people need to survive. This is what wrong with pet owner, when you put a name on any animal you get attached to it, so you feel like enforcing it to everybody who doesn’t give a damn, but only to think where will  the next meal to live for another day.

  • Laura B.

    Very few Americans, except for large corporations who save money breeding animals in poor conditions and slaughtering animals with little respect or gratefulness for the energy they provide, thinks animals should be treated the way they are. Human diseases have been created here in America due to poor animal conditions.

  • Laura B.

    Yeah, doing the right thing is stupid.

  • -rolls eyes-

    I’m not going to deny this– yes this will sound racist. But then again, I don’t expect a person from a country that is so enclosed in their own bubble that anything that is different is deemed oh so wrong. Face it– your chicken was murdered so you could eat it. Your fish too. They didn’t willingly give up their meat. In the end– you, in some sense is ‘desensitized to animal cruelty’. It simply is that, while you regard this animal as a PET, they regard it as MEAT.

    Americans.

  • Leverseaux

    I am offensive and I find this Asian.

  • kidding me?

    LOL just because a handful of people commit a certain act does not mean the whole entire billion plus race is like that. Learn to be less ignorant. It’s like saying Americans are nothing but warmongers based on the action of few.

  • bored of internet know-it-alls

    erm, i might be a little late, but, i’ve travelled to asia… and they
    DO eat a number of animals that we in the western world dont consider to
    be ‘eating animals’…. melissa is right to comment on their choice of food, if she classifies it as a disregard for life, thats her prerogative. Although i would be interested to know if she is a vegan…if not, some would say she has a pretty healthy disregard for life too.
    To call someone racist when you yourself use their culture as a an example of stupidity is being as ignorant and racist as you believe she is.
    And commenting that people can be vile towards each other in a tone that suggest you are not, while openly calling someone racist and mocking their opinion, even if it is questionable, is as vile as it gets.
    Mockery and sarcasm are never an intelligent form of response.
    Perhaps you ALL need to do some research before plastering your ignorant opinions all over the internet.

  • you = silly racist

    yeah, no, you’re racist. you don’t just “sound” it; you are.

  • Chippertracey

    Cool. Where can I get one

  • Kevin Lin

    I am Asian but I Prefer to Save the Animal’s and Free Them because Im in Florida I just Brought an Pet Turtle an Care for it as long as it I can I wouldn’t do any bad things to Animals I would Protect Them / Even If Someone or like my Family Trys To Im gonna call 991 not matter if they are my Family because i have taken care of an turtle for 12 months so I understand Turtles so I will Protect Them
     
     
    I’m Asian , but really i hate Asian’s because they do all these Bad Things To The Animals
     
     
    I trade my life for Animals
       I Love Turtles an I will become an Police when I am a Adult Whoever Try’s to eat an Turtle or Some Pet I’ll Arrest Them To Jail or I’ll Become an President when I grow up and Make The Laws !

  • Sniderserena

    I have tons of friends FROM Asia who grew up eating dog. dont be so fucking stupid.

  • guest

    While it sounded extremely racist, dont dodge the acutal points she was making. How many videos have you seen filmed in America where a woman was crushing a kittens head with her stilettos? DIDNT FUCKING THINK SO. Atleast there is evidence of what shes saying, your just a fucking sheeple. and that mother fucker above you, is anything bt brilliant. so shut the fuck up.

  • guest

    even if this isn’t real its gross! and cruel. I would buy tons of them then cut the bags open and heep them as pets!

  • Why do this?

    By saying Asians u offended other asians that feel offended about these stuff. I’m asian and i disapprove of eating dogs and live creatures in key-chains.

  • Poppinlockin

    Do we know what companies are doing this? We need to make a petition to find and target these disgusting companies

  • Sannafae

    basically u cant save the whole world…people, animals, plants and all…keep the peace by being at peace within yourself..

  • Bitchface

    Look i agree that’s pretty depressing… but you know nothing bout how asians really are. i’m in china and been to A LOT of the subway stations here, not once have i seen a keychain like that. The media exaggerates a lot things happening and comments like yours is plain bullcrap. You fucking americans also travel around and eat a lot of shit asians make, so shut the fuck up bout how we are. 

  • Frozenccool

    Can’t believe people would do such thing :/

  • Zgb

    Sick bastards…

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/PSGGIVQLPGO4RLTKKB6TPVBMWY Nom

    By buying them you’re supporting it. Whether you’re releasing them
    or not, that just gives them the funds to continue their operations.
    While it’s disgusting, buying them to set them free isn’t going to solve
    this…
     

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=514972020 Susan Haddeland

    My heart weeps for humanity and all the Earth’s creatures who suffer at our hands.  It is horrific what some people will do to make a buck!  

  • Nicole

    All of you who are regarding Asians as cruel animal abusers, think again. I was born and raised in China, and I’m still living here. I’m 100% Chinese. I’ve seen keychains like this, and yes, they disgust me. They disgust hundreds of other Chinese people I’ve met too. Just because a handful of us have committed disgusting acts like this doesn’t mean we’re all like that. Asians don’t seem to have a whole lot of regard for life? I’ve seen many, many local Chinese people bringing in stray cats and dogs. A huge amount of the Chinese population is Buddhist, which means that a lot of us are either vegetarian, or we don’t eat beef and other large animals. You’re sorry to sound racist? You know that you’re offending us, then why bother posting this comment in the first place? By the way, those who are calling “Lol” ignorant, think about Melissa Robertson-Noriega first. She’s regarding us Asians, a whole race, as horrible people. She’s saying that we were raised to eat puppies. What bullshit.

  • Nicole

    You obviously haven’t been to China. Don’t judge the whole race just because some of us have done some stupidly awful things. Please, grow up and get some education.

  • Nicole

    As long as it’s one of the Chinese involved in the trade. See, I’m a Chinese too. This thing completely disgusts me, and your stereotypes too.

  • Nicole

    You still claimed that you’ll never visit this beautiful country just because of the minority of the population are sick assholes like this.

  • Nicole

    So you’re regarding the whole Chinese race as a whole? I agree with Sduhfd. You’re a fucking idiot. None of the points you described above apply to the Chinese people that I know. And I live in China.

  • Tino

    There is absolutely, in no way, a difference between eating dogs and pigs. Both are intelligent, sentinent beings. So not only was that post racist, but also speciesist. Good job.

  • Karol

    It would be a good idea to seal owner of that bussiness in a plastic bag

  • http://twitter.com/Jack_le_Critic Jack le Critic

    If it’s real – it’s appalling. It’s bizarre how Chinese culture appears immune to the sensitivity of creatures…surely there must be some animal welfare groups out there?

  • Italianbella33

    I am sickened by this. This needs to be addressed and stopped! Why is this being allowed?!

  • Shing12

    You sound more judgmental than racist! Isn’t it that ABORTION is legal in your country?!! Then how the hell would you call AMERICANS??? Yours is even worst!!!

  • Shing12

    What if these chines vendors will also be sealed in a plastic and drowned with a “nutrient rich” liquid?? We’ll see how they survive…sometimes for this people to learn lessons in life, they must be treated the way they treat living creatures that God created….Isn’t it that a CHINESE named Confucius once said “Do not do to others what you don’t want others to do unto you!” The Golden Rule!!! What an irony!!! now his own bloodline are doing things against his own teachings!!!!

  • sarcastic

     Do you think they could make like a purse size one and fit a small puppy or kitten in there too? Wouldn’t that be cute!

  • http://twitter.com/debx3 Debbie

    PLEASE do not generalize the term ‘ASIAN’.

  • Ellie

    But really, isn’t eating a puppy similar to eating a lamb? They’re both baby animals that just want to live their life. Their culture is different to ours and whilst they are brought up eating puppies we also eat animals on a daily basis. However, either way they shouldn’t be suffocating turtles and fish in plastic containers leading them to a slow and painful death. Basically torturing them. 

    A Weird invention from some greedy money grabbing moron – I hope someone locks him/her in a plastic bag. I wonder how how they would like it. 

  • Doctormedo

     HERE IS NOT THE QUESTION WHO’S RASIST OR NOT!! HERE IS THE PROBLEM THAT THOUSANDS OF LITTLE TURTLES AND FISHES ARE DIEING!

  • Abc

     Whats bad about that?

  • Harmgrace

    How mean !!”

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1424726534 Shelley Fyfe

    I’m beginning to feel that human kindness is a myth or indeed a rarity, we’ll be eating each other soon.

  • Shedden2u

    I’m astounded at how the Chinese government are so fucked up to actually allow this.

  • sjjleo

    Good god are you sorry to sounds racist? Or do you revel in it? ASIANS “don’t seem to have a lot of regard for life” because of the traditional cultural practice of eating dog meat? What about the other 5.9 billion people worldwide who eat meat if they get the chance? 

    Then again I can’t speak, I was raised to eat cute little chicks and adorable fish.

    Bigotry  in every sense of the word. 

  • Roshaan Amber

    I am an asian and I find this absolutely wrong. Just becuz some people are doing this does not mean you’re supposed to blame the whole race! But yes, this is disgusting.

  • Foxi_tails

    There are many countries in Asia where people do eat dogs (and no, I’m not American, and yes, I have lived in Asia and seen it for myself)  My question is, how is eating dogs any more cruel than eating pigs, or chickens, or cows?  Asians probably do have a different attitude to animal cruelty than, say Europeans, but when human life is precarious, why would animal welfare be a major concern.  Nevertheless, this does seem to be an extremely unfortunate trend, especially considering the wildlife implications of all those released Brazilian turtles.

  • Sandy_mac_donald

    LOL…Americans crying about turtles while bombing children in Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya.  LMAO… Americans planning to bomb children in Iran – while continuing to cry about turtles…

  • LMS

    Yes. It’s all Americans. 
    As a matter of fact, I made sure to send over a bomb while I was out at the grocery store today. Hope it made it there ok!

    You’re an idiot. 

  • Sebastian

    Goddamn, you deserve some kind of trophy for racist ignorance. Eating dog does not desensitize one to animal cruelty, just as eating chicken does not desensitize most Americans. Just because you keep a dog for a pet does not make it a viable option for a food source. (Indians probably think we are appalling for eating cows. It’s all relative, but if you can’t see that, you’re dumb as bricks and there’s no point talking to you.)

    That being said, certainly there are people in China who are either oblivious to animal suffering, or financially exploiting animal cruelty for personal gain, or so poor that they will rely on whatever means necessary to feed themselves and their family. There’s no shortage of people in North America that exhibit appallingly cruel behaviour to animals in the name of profit, and those are often the people that raise our animals for food, which means that many of us actively continue to support that industry.

    (I eat meat although I hate animal cruelty. No intentions of becoming a vegetarian any time soon, either. But just saying that demonizing “Asians” and painting them with one brush on the basis of the actions of a few is unbelievably narrow-minded and ridiculously racist.)

  • Sebastian

     *err… “does not NOT make it a viable option for a food source”

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Christine-Glo/100001716300638 Christine Glo

    ok it is cruel… but Chinese (not all of them) have an other relationship to animals like Germans, Romanians and so on.

    Whereever in the world the Humans eat animals witch are holy in other countries and reverse…  I am sure, a Chinese one buys such an animal, because there it is normaly. Also on chinese markets it is normaly to buy, insekts, or worms ore everything that loolks cruel for us from Germany. But really, i wouldn’t drink a coctail from a monkeybrain witch is killed in front of my eyes etc. And bye the way: asians eat dogs!!! In China, Vietnam, and Burma! I know that not from TV, i know that from a friend of us, who is married with an vietnam man. When he came to Germany he had to learn to agreee that his “meal” walks on the streat holded by the line by a nice german woman……..They really have public feasts when dogs are slaughtered

  • um yeah…

    Im sorry but last i heard people in SWITZERLAND eat dogs too.. so i guess they’re just asian now.

  • asian

    excuse me go fuck yourself bastard american,..you don’t even know wat ur talking about…read about your history before judging others okay?…for a country like china who havn’t law forbiding that kind,you cannot stop them for doing it…just like there at you’re place where there’s no law forbidding fucking along the street it’s just like normal.:D

    IT DEPENDS UPON THE CULTURE OF EACH OF US…BUT ABOUT THIS,.ONLY THE CONCERNED AGENCIES/DEPARTMENTS/BUREAU/PEOPLE SHOULD BE MENTIONED CRUEL NOT AN ENTIRE RACE OF “ASIANS”…idiot-uneducated american  Melissa Robertson-Noriega!

  • Liar_ian

    so what ur saying?there in america they’re not even selling fish to eat?why is that they are importing?idiot-fishes are made to be a food of man..go school and you will learn about food chain/web!..

  • Nomi_zafar

    You have generalised 4 billion people in one term, ‘Asians!’. There’s a huge world outside your US which is massive and very vibrant. In ‘such’ Asians you get Hindus who are vegetarians and alot more others who don’t look Chinese but still are called Asians!  I’d suggest you should brush up on your geography at least!

  • Stephi Diasz

    ugh

  • Bina

    I hope animal activists/protection get on this issue RIGHT AWAY, this is disgusting. Who in their right minds would put a living creature into a plastic bag for aesthetics?!

     It does not make you look cute carrying a doomed living thing on your wrist/cellphone/keychain, etc.. it makes you look like a murderer and a supporter of animal cruelty.

    Be ashamed of yourself, you’re disgusting. 

  • Trexrb

    I honestly would buy them just to keep and raise to good health then release. people   should be shot for doing this and yes that everyone not just 1 race

  • Generalizemuch?

    Hi Melissa, if you can at least try to use what’s left of your income to venture out into the real world and see for yourself if “Asians” are really who you think they are, then perhaps the life you’ve been living wouldn’t be as pathetically shallow. Perhaps you can also try to use ‘Some Asians’, in future. It makes a whole lot of difference.

  • Efewf

    Some Asians eat puppies,all Americans eat beef,pork,lamb and so on and you know,those animals do not grow on trees.

  • ladycanuck

    I just find this wrong !!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1828438093 Ka’uilani Kim

    God doesn’t have karma… 

  • Anon

    how much ?

  • Dneed

    America is not a race  

  • Anonymous

    What is your point? “I’ve seen cruelty on live dog and cat markets in Asia”–yes, I think we’ve already agreed that ANIMAL CRUELTY EXISTS IN ASIA. And guess what? It also exists here in America, in Europe, and many other regions in the world. Please do not try to use the dog issue to generalize “Asians” as cruel toward animals. Here in the U.S. the chicken produce company TYSON is involved with animal cruelty–as is KFC. And that is only to name a few. I personally am against dog-eating, but I also respect the fact that THAT IS PART OF THEIR CULTURE. We need to stop viewing the world from an “AMERICA IS THE BEST, AMERICANS ARE ALWAYS RIGHT” attitude. Just think about it–when cows and lamb and pigs are slaughtered as food for us Americans here, can you be sure that the animals here weren’t “skinned alive and beaten to death” when you try to judge someone based on so little knowledge you have on that specific topic, think about yourself; think about the animal cruelty that does exist in America, and then see if you still have the right to criticize and call a country cruel. *and to everyone–WHY MUST YOU SPECIFY WHAT ETHNICITY YOU ARE IN YOUR COMMENTS? It doesn’t make us all any more credible; all we need to do is get a point across to these people. By specifying our ethnicity, we’re only drawing a thicker line between Asia and America. I apologize if this offended anybody–I’m not trying to argue or target you, Lynn, I’m only trying to stop the ignorance and generalization. And it’s not just about Asians; if your attitude toward something foreign is like this, then you will be as ignorant as you are with every other issue that deals with foreign matters.

  • Nancy Green

    This is so disgusting.These people have no feelings.It makes me sick.They will get theirs.

  • Asdda

    Sick idiots.. -.-

  • ID10T

     I’m sorry to make you sound like an idiot now, but I can’t seem to understand why is it the Eastern Culture, (what was it labelled as again? oh right!) Asians happens to be so far advance regarding their lives? As cruel as it is, they’re marketing schemed work whether it makes them look good or look bad, they’re still collecting money. Its a booming business for people thinks it’s cool and people who pity for the little creatures. You buy them because you thought it was cute and cool, you buy them so you can set them free, point here regardless of your reason to buy, you still bought them. So level of getting customers spending their money to buy your product regardless of reasons/morals: ASIANS.

  • Sherlockme

    it is not because Asians are racist, Asians have these culture that eating animals were just part of their lifestyle as a tribe, which I can say tribes influenced these modern people..

  • ID10T

    you are an idiot… Not only you tried to justified yourself smart, you did it well as a racist ignorant. Apparently, over here in Asia, we don’t care about Animal rights….

  • ID10T

     p.s my previous post was a lot more harsher, you should be happy that the administrator of this site took it down.

  • Caballero007

    I think this is absolutly horrendious. What’s mostly frustrating is why, as human

    I think this is absolutely horrendous. What’s frustrating
    is why, as rational human beings, we would accept that such a disgusting trend
    would ever become popular. I guess I answered my own question, rational?

    .

  • DrRedWood

    Id buy them, then cut the bag (not cut them) and keep them as my own pet.
     Thats just cruel, Id rather give them a second chance then let them die in that tiny bag.

  • fishkiller

    How is this any different than giving goldfish away in little glass bowls as carnival prizes?  Has anyone ever kept one of those things alive more than a week before forgetting about it and finding it belly up?  At least the Chinese eat theres when they die and dont waste them, we just flush them down the toilet, so who is worse?

  • Nate

    But some Asians do eat puppies and dogs…

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002880531850 Rhiannon Avaneen

     In many areas of asia they DO eat cats and dogs. They break the dogs legs repeatedly to keep them subservient and tender and they boil the cats alive in a large pot of water.

  • Krazyyobochic

    I’m Asian and I do not eat dog or would buy such a non act of animal cruelty in a bag… Use ur words wisely perhaps asian countries instead of Asians in general..

  • Krazyyobochic

    A nonsense act of animal cruelty

  • Krazyyobochic

    Nonsense act of animal cruelty…

  • jessica

    :’c

  • Hypocrite

    Yet most of mankind eat animals and exploit them, this compares very little to the actions most have already proceeded. People ought to think of what the animals they wear, use as pets, watch on tv or a zoo, and slaughter and eat before they begin protesting to ban these key chains. This is just another reminder of how human engages their power in natural hierarchy. Summary: don’t get all sad and depressed and call this disgusting when you exploit animals in worst ways every day.

  • Faith_molly

    OMG Free the turtles </3

  • M13online

    I live in Taiwan which according to some is part of China. And I’ve been to China. And Melissa isn’t “racist” she just has common sense. In China they eat anything and everything and they treat animals as objects. When they kill a dog they torture it to death. That way its meat has lots of adrenaline in it from the pain. They also eat aborted fetuses. People in China have been brought up to put no value on life. Human or animal. My wife and son are Chinese…..so don’t you idiots call me racist as well. Just because someone knows a TRUE FACT about a certain race…..doesn’t make them racist.

  • M13

    Melissa has barely touched the tip of the iceberg. The practices in China are beyond disgusting. Search “China orphanage” on youtube to see how much value the Chinese put on life. They tie 2 year olds to chairs and let them sit in their own shit for an entire day before tying them to a bed. I know it’s considered “cool” to be “politically correct” in America and all….but the truth is the truth. And Melissa’s only fault is being too soft on the Chinese.

  • Dark_knightxz

    This is so sick! I’m Asian and I’m ashame of this thing happens in my region! I’m willing to buy those turtle to free them..

  • Kim

    Have you ever seen a KFC-chicken farm? Or how the meat at McDonald’s is treated when it’s alive? Honestly, Americans are NOT in position to critique on animal cruelty.

  • Gabriel

    Let’s put chinese babies inside colored plastic bags with water in it and let’s hang them in our houses, cars or workplaces so they give us good luck!!! When they die just throw it to the garbagge after all chinese people’s not an endangered species. . Let’s see what they think about it.

  • Jo-anie

    Ce commerce à été créé par quelques cons. Ce commerce continue à cause des centaines ou des milliers de cons qui achètent et encouragent ces cons à continuer. Plus d’acheteurs, plus de profits et plus de commerces c’est tout. Osti que le monde est con criss

  • Veronika

    I dare to say that eating weird things is not the same as putting them into keychains and letting them die of hunger and lack of oxygen. Lots of people eat different things that others, even within their own culture,  find disgusting – ordinary seafood being a great example of this- but at least it is EATING! 
    I read posts that say this message is a hoax and other ones that claim that people are selling them as pets etc. The trouble is all of them might very well be true – and I kind of hope that they are. Selling an animal in a plastic bag with coloured water is not ok and I hope the people who buy them are more sensible that the ones who sell them.

  • Ladiu

    buy them all and FREE THE ANIMALS !!!

  • DIGGO

    Not sure if extremely dumb or just trolling

  • Nincs

    The reason we have racism is because many races have “attacked” and invaded america and mainly europe (chinese, pakistanis, indians, africans) and they refused to integrate. That’s very disrespectful I think, since they live in a society that was built by us, and had nothing to do with them. The least they could do is learn the language? haha

  • Payalagwl

    its shocking ,PETA shoud do smthing

  • Email Co Uk

    Post the link, let us see if the majority of Asia do it as many people said it is.

  • Email Uk Co

    You just mention a specific country, however if you know geography, Asia is not just Japan, china or Philippines, as it has many countries and they are all in Asia. Perhaps you know about Europe, it has many countries and they are all in Europe. So be more specific, and remember that everyone is an individual, as even a son of a cannibal can be a vegan or herbivores, by choice. So them people who did nasty things are f***up head, can’t label the country and it’s population and be predudice about it.

  • Asdf

    pussys

  • Hatism_whites

    I am sorry to sound racists, but Americans are stupid.

  • you’re racist Melissa

    I agree, i myself am asian. Born in Australia but family born in china. I disagree with this whole animal in baggy thing but Melissa has no right to say this. Americans eat so much meat it could probably equal the atrociousness of this. People need to stop. And frankly, a lot of the products that test on animals are originated in America

  • Let’s not be ignorant.

    I’m Chinese, born in China now living in America. microwave and eat with beer? YEAH RIGHT. I mean, it’s semi believable that they make such keychains… I mean, Asians are very creative in their means of making money… I’m not saying what they’re doing is right, but I’m saying that some people here are writing stories and books about things they don’t even know. Just because you hear a story about some stupid people eating dogs, doesn’t mean everyone eats dogs. (and I’m so tired of people asking me if I eat dogs!!) I don’t believe in animal cruelty, but if you’re going to raise your voice about a goldfish, why haven’t you done anything for sea food, sushi, chicken, etc… why don’t you write about your hot dogs, hamburgers, and kfc??

    Oh and…. if the fish/turtles can live in that bag for a couple of months…. then they MUST be doing SOMETHING right… normally they’d probably last a day or two tops.

  • bs

    “People in China have been brought up to put no value on life.” That is complete bullshit.

  • Minerva

    Being hateful in response to something you disagree with, doesn’t make you right. It makes you just as bad.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1277918396 Cheryl Ann

    Not true. I am Asian . None of my friends, family nor anyone I know of eat dogs or cats or anything that people from other country would call exotic.  Though I would agree that there are people who are desensitized to such cruelty, I dont think it is fair to be associated to that moron vendor.

  • Realist

    I don’t like them selling live animals and I hate when animals get to live a shitty life just for the foods sake. Even cultural things should not go that far. But, if I am to interfear with the guys above. What is really the difference between eating a puppy and eating a pig? Or cow or chicken? You see, it is just a cultural thing what we think is disgusting to eat and not. In china, I guess this is culture, proparly an old tradition (Whitch I think should be removed). But in the western countries, the big slaughtering companies and often horrible to the animals. People can’t work there for more than a year! 

  • Guest

    I can understand eating the animals… but keeping them alive in little bags like that, is just torture

  • Charliesheen

      Melissa Robertson-Noriegagrouping all asians as these Chinese vendors is like grouping all caucasians  as Nazis..just ’cause you look similar doesn’t mean you’re the same.Try judging people as individuals and not as a whole.

  • Birdytweety58

    For everyone’s information, some parts of Asia, aka China, have made it illegal to eat dogs about a year ago. This could be due to the realization of animal cruelty, or the Chinese government realizing that it puts China as a bad image to the rest of the world. Call it what you want, but America meddles too much in everyone’s business.

  • http://www.facebook.com/SugarFrostedBRAINZ Haylee Burdette

    I hate that this is so cruel, because I honestly like the idea of carrying around a turtle in my back pocket (as long as it wasn’t being killed slowly and whatnot).

    I don’t know if I would buy these to set them free, because if you buy from vendors, they just get more money to make these. It’s like if you buy a CD from a band you hate, you’re just giving them more money to make music with… 
    All in all this is really sad. :(

  • Pochacco001

    First, you are not sorry to sound racist. Please think about that again or else you would not have said it. I am Asian and it is really disrespectful and ignorant to say what you just said about me. Second, in that part of the world, dogs are what they eat. Like here cows are what you eat here. juSt because an animal is not domesticated does not mean it’s not food. it please please learn the culture before speaking. Third, America isn’t doing so hot with killing cows,chickens, and etc in terrible ways as well. Its not just Asia.Fourth, kids in America are taught to eat things that we Asians dont understand why Americans eat.people are all different and eat different things because they have different tastes. Give someone ketchup and they dont like it, you can’t tell them they have to eat it because it’s better than mustard because it’s more humane to eat tomatoes because eating mustard is down right wrong. Dog is food to them. How chicken is food to us. Yes it is wrong to torture them while they are still alive. I agree. That’s not just Asians. Its all over the world. And yes we do eat a lot of things that make it seem like we eat everything but you and everyone else need to understand that people who eat dogs and cats dont see them as pets. A cow could be their pet and wonder why Americans eat cow when they are considered pets. but you know, I agree that having these animals in a closed small bag is cruel. Its not right. And we eat turtles but not when they are like that. We dont eat animals that are like that. Its not healthy. But those who do are the non educated people who dont understand that they are eating a turtle that is not healthy and will get sick from it. bUt people do dumb things all over the world like this.

  • German_ray

    but yet again u got people getting shot at the border and people in countries fighting to get potable water haha americans are so funny lets worry about creatures because thats makes us feel more humane. fuck all the other people we fuck because we treat animals better than illegal immigrants and blacks. god bless the ethnocentric america. btw IM SORRY TO SOUND RACIST….

  • German_ray

    but yet again u got people getting shot at the border and people in countries fighting to get potable water haha americans are so funny lets worry about creatures because thats makes us feel more humane. fuck all the other people we fuck because we treat animals better than illegal immigrants and blacks. god bless the ethnocentric america. btw IM SORRY TO SOUND RACIST…. but it appears that most americans are bubble heads that use subjects like this to make themselves feel better…

  • Mariarmfranco

    I’M ASIAN BITCH BUT I DON’T EAT DOG SO NEXT TIME YOU SHOULD PUT “SOME ASIANS”…STUPID ILLITERATE BITCH!…BYE

  • http://twitter.com/MrNovan Novan

    Americans dont seem to have a whole lot of regard for life. With hundreds of thousands of combined innocent Afghanis, Iraqis, Syrians (the list goes on) dead, they’re probably pretty desensitized to all human cruelty. They kill EVERYTHING it seems. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Keith-Stephen-modeste/100001746933071 Keith Stephen-modeste

    what will man do next do they not know this is a life like any other no more torment please

  • Rhaina Love

    This makes me sick to my stomach!!!! How can someone actually do such a thing??? there’s a place for sick people like….

  • Saliyy

    This should be illegal. I don’t know how people don’t feel guilty for the shit they do to animals. This is beyond sick.  Sick ass people are going to hell for being so cold hearted.

  • Arnv

    Only a twisted people can do this and hw can sm one let it b. if govt is blind doesthat mean the people r too. this is beginning of the end of human.

  • Random

    um have you seen what we do to chickens and cows?

  • Lizzy

    Oh my gosh, this is horrible. I would go to one of these and buy out the cart to free the animals.thar is just so sick. What has the world come too?

  • Horrockstribe

    Appalling isn’t even a strong enough word to describe this practice….

  • Sweet_disaster310

    I would like to put the people who made this in a plastic bag with no air and “nutrients” and see how they like it!

  • Amused

    Brilliant. We are all vile to one another, so let’s all get off topic of the actual thing and make random replies to people. We are all desensitized to each other, possibly. In other words, maybe giving information rather than ganging up would be a better idea. But as for the turtle in the bag. I’d be the crazy turtle lady, for sure. I don’t care who’m supporting, but I prefer to free the buggers.

  • Rachaellloyd33

    Horrible and the ppl who buy them just as disgusting, unless they are freeing them, to watch a animal die for entertainment is evil.

  • Fhadking11

    cant blame all Asians. more than 50% of Asian’s are vegetarian and would not even touch meats 

  • Fahad

    this took place in china and why are u blaming all Asians as Asians include Indians toooo. india have no role in these type of activities. and dont think all Chinese people enjoy such things!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

  • Lweisedel

    Unbelieveably sad and disgusting…I would buy them all just to set them free!

  • Lizzybug

    its so sad i want to go to china buy a how lot of the turtles and put them in a nice home

  • http://www.facebook.com/Ninjaprints Henry Clayton

    dont suppose any of you may have put any thought into the science behind keeping an animal alive for the claimed 1 – 3 months without oxygen?

    it simply is not possible.

    odd that this article has popped up two years running on April the 1st eh?

    Whilst everything points towards hoax, there are some unfortunately realistic videos showing turtles thrashing in bags, though I would say I am 70% leaning towards it being a hoax, and 30% leaning towards being disgusted further with the world if wrong.

  • Phillybreadclothing

    This is wild and that comment was very racist. Not all Americans think that way! No wonder other countries hate us or don’t understand us we think we’re better than everyone that’s not us. Get a clue, no matter where your from we’re all the same and true some are harden to death and cruelty but aren’t there cannibals in America?? Isnt that much worse than an animal that ALL our ancestors ate at one point in time. Think about what your thinking before you type and make our country look like a bunch of inbreed idiots.

  • Fidora

    i want to thow up

  • Fidora/Germany

    throw up … ;)

  • Harli

    So sick of the bloody Chinese being do fricking cruel to every animal they get their hands on just to make money. F##king morons, I hope you all suffer the same fate at sometime in your pathetic lives!!

  • Dansonfoo

    As an Asian, I can safely say that you are not racist but quite ignorant.Asia is a combination of over 2.5 billion people .  And many of us do not eat dogs and cats, in fact we account for a higher hollywood movie box office, purchase more laptops and phones ( iphones and blackberries ) than the US.  Equating all Asians to the Chinese and equating all Chinese to the idiots who are making these key chains is the same as Asians thinking that all Americans are either on coke or meth, carry 2 handguns, shoot up schools, either live in a fancy house or in a trailer and is segregated to 2 races. ( In case the sarcasm is missed, all of the above is NOT true ).

  • http://www.facebook.com/Love.Aalea Aaleayha Englese

    Kind of like southerners and their alligators? Yet we have LEGAL shows to watch some back hicks killing alligators for food and people starting “whale wars” which is basically attacking another countries ships (which is illegal). And … I’m American.
    Point is, animals are animal. Just because one person keeps it as a pet doesn’t mean it can’t be a food source. What you have is what you have.
    And no, I don’t approve the turtle key chains. Though Americans eat turtle and fish as well, we don’t keep them alive in a key chain before hand.

  • Jmshelokitty

    why not buy it and take them out of the ‘bag’ and keep it as a pet? 

  • Moonunitenar

    Does anyone remember the kittens in bottles that were supposedly being sold a few years back? Don’t believe everything you read on the internet, kiddos.

  • Sar 03 01

    who the hell would do that, pls people no one should be supporting for this cruel marketing.. try some other ways to make money you…. 

  • Serablank

    This is going to happen anyway in this country, so I have a
    question & please respond if you may be able to help answer this…..If I
    were to purchase one of these…whether a turtle or 2 king fish…could I be
    able to receive them still alive here, in the U.S. & keep them as pets?
    Giving them a chance to live a full life! Maybe it doesn’t solve the problem on
    a wide scale but…..? What does everyone think? This is sort of thinking out
    loud situation!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=655247197 Dennis M O’Leary

    animal rights groups can cry all they want.. its in freakin china and BTW damn deliscious

  • Nope

     You do realize that they raise dogs, like we raise cattle.

  • Tiaparrado

    and what would happen if you opened the bag and freed them!! ?
     

  • Savannah X _97

    Wtf this is so disgusting and wrong!!!!!!!!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1496641672 Akiko Fujishima

    Melissa, I suggest you take a long hard look at your comment and how blatantly stupid it is.  I’m an Asian and I would NEVER harm an animal, I don’t even eat meat or ANY animal product for crying out loud!  Why don’t you take a walk though an American live stock farm, and tell me how cruelty free it is, and it’s perfectly legal how those animals are treated..  Humans in general are stupid and cruel, just some more than others.. apparently shooting a cow through the skull with a metal rod  (they don’t always die instantly)..ripping a new born calf from it’s mother and shoving it into a crate that it can’t even lay down in for the next 8 months of it’s life until it’s slaughtered for veal is not cruel at all but you can turn a blind eye to that, because it’s not in your face on the web like this is.. right?

  • Caterpillargirl123

    WTF they should let them be, what did they do to us other then give us joy. My daughter had cancer and I took her to go see them. I have never in my life smile more then when she saw the turtles swimming about. Some people need to become the animals and see how they feel.
    RS

  • Caterpillargirl123

    I know right

  • Princess1965

    This must be like being buried alive. Poor little mites… So sad

  • CAROLINE EMMERSON

    another depressing animal story I’ve heard within these two week. The first being the slaughter of the rhinos and elephants.

  • Peter

     Yeah, but American deer, elk and bear hunters have “regard for life”. Sure.

  • Todd

    I think that they should put some of these Asians in a bag for awhile and see how humane it is.

  • Jp Boucher

    It’s no worse than having fish in a tank at the grocery. I’ve eaten turtle and it’s awesome but it’s a cultural thing its all my mother in law eats chicken feet my little brother has eaten a dog I’m canadian I’m a carnivor. When will we stop telling other people what is wright and wrong this is how you create an enemy this is how you start a war.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Chantilly-Bong/100003652515599 Chantilly Bong

     its not all asian. asshole. its the mainland chinese from CHINA.

  • Siresh

    its very very bad how can they be so cruel….  there r so many better alternatives to lead life nd earn money

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1095230804 Maurice Spees

    It’s like a horror movie. The only way something like this stops is when a disease breaks out, while it is a disease in itself. What about the chinese Karma?

  • Jmoo

    ROT IN HELL YOU DISGUSTING HUMAN BEINGS

  • Jmoo

    lol what a moron comment. Doesn’t matter where you come from its common knowledge to treat all living things , including plants and trees with respect.If you cant do that, well then you’re not a human being, you’re not a animal of this universe, you’re a pile of crap

  • Kryzakimmel

    You could just tell her,” No, that is not true. And yes that is racist. She wasn’t being vile.

  • Mill200

    Are you serious, believe everything we read, how about fish skinned, fried and served still alive, monkey brains eaten whilst the animal is not only alive but awake under a table with its mouth tied, and this is only an example, I suppose we should be grateful that the poor animal dies before it is eaten

  • http://www.dog-barrier.com/ heated dog beds

    as they reportedly watched one fish keychain and nine turtle keychains
    sell in five minutes time, to both people who think they’re neat, and
    others who buy the keychains to free the animals.

  • Person5347

    THAT IS TERRIBLE !!!  I would get those key chains to FREE the poor animals.The only problem with that is that would give them money to make more. This is just are CRUEL and TERRIBLE thing to do to animals.

  • Nico

    turn TV off! ..then Open a Book,,, it will be an exciting new experience! 

  • Tyler

    lets all buy one to free the turtle from its cruel fate

  • Judi

    Melissa isn’t talking rubbish here, and I don’t think she’s being racist. There is certainly a market for dog and cat flesh in China and some other parts of Asia, and the animals are treated horribly prior to being killed. I know this to be fact, not only because I have read numerous reports and seen numerous photographs, but because my good friend spent 4 years living and teaching in China and she has told me first hand stories that would make you weep.  The people who sell dogs for meat believe that if the animal feels fear and pain before death, then the adrenaline makes the meat more delicious. They do not regard this as cruel, because they don’t regard animals as thinking beings but only as commodities there for their use and pleasure. They may be extremely kind to people, but animals do not matter. This is not condemning all Asian people, there are many even in China that strive against cruelty and for better lives for animals, but the disregard of animals is strongly ingrained in many. China still has no laws against animal cruelty, because it is not recognised as wrong by the government.

  • Jollytollie624

    i would cut open the bag and keep the turtle as a pet…

  • hoormehr

     what can we do to stop this shit?!:(

  • Hyperlite33

    Melissa is correct. Asian cultures typically value animal life much differently that the Western civilizations. It’s not racist. It’s a fact based on socioeconomic factors, and years of desensitization of animal rights.    

    Stop saying that things are racist simply because it’s easier for you to categorize rather than research.  

  • Ellie_k11

    If you put a pile of shit in plastic floating in colored water … eventually an Asian will eat it. So smart … yet so incredibly dumb, cruel and disgusting.

  • http://african-mango-extract.com/ african mangos

    The mission is to capure the “live music feel”, and hopefully get to talk to some of the artists. Right now though,

  • some people…

    Melissa, your level of ignorance disgusts me. It wouldn’t surprise me if you turned out to be a gigantic hypocrite.

  • Lalala

    :( poor little animals ! I’m raising awareness of this at my school. . I’m even making a online petition!!,!!!!

  • Xosportschic97ox

    I would buy a ton of them, just to set the poor guys free..

  • Veronika

    I would probably buy some too,but the trouble is the more of them you buy, the more you support the trade with them. The sellers do not care whether you buy them to release them or tow ear them as keychains, they get money from it and thats what they want. So I guess buying and releasing a bunch makes just more room for catching and imprisoning more. I just dont understand what a sick person it has to be to really buy it as a keychain. And I read it is getting popular with children at schools and so on – but have they got no parents FFS???

  • Angry Customer

    some countries have customs which others think are strange and unacceptable. But this one really is.  Granted, these creatures don’t live long anyway, but they deserve a better life than this.  The only way these vendors might stop is if it’s illegal – but even then, that just might drive up the price.

  • Bluskii

    You know what, I’m Asian and sadly, I sorta agree with you. Not all Asians are like that but obviously there are many out there that follow what you say.

  • Bettanoom

    I thought it was just a rumor but this picture shows everything…No body wants to do anything about it?it’s murdering…what a world…

  • Disgusted Reader.

    We eat cows, pigs, chickens, and who knows what else. Whether or not they eat dogs (which I am not going to get into) is just another example of eating meat. Just because our culture keeps them mainly as pets doesn’t mean everyone should.

  • http://www.sooperarticles.com/home-improvement-articles/heating-air-conditioning-articles/how-avoid-heat-pump-problems-956022.html heat pump troubleshooting

     as they reportedly watched one fish keychain and nine turtle keychains
    sell in five minutes time, to both people who think they’re neat, and
    others who buy the keychains to free the animals.

  • Ad101090

    “so it’s just like us Americans having little to no regard for the poor animals we eat” <- what's your point then if you just refuted it? eating other creatures is a natural process. what do you think burgers are made of? and what's with the whole  "puppy" thing? are chickens' lives not as important as puppies because they aren't as cute and lovable? get a grip. this has nothing to do with the nationality of the people but rather the fact that animal cruelty is present in the world.

  • voiceofreason

    You must be racist or at least uneducated to not realize that “American” is not a race.  Good work, now get back in your hole.

  • sue

    pretty much the same thing happens to most of the animals in factory farms. This keychain business is horrible, but remember so are battery chicken farms, dairy farms and so on. know how food and clothes and everything you use is produced. Often there are animals that suffer to produce those things. utilize the internet, know the truths! It will change your diet and the way you live :-)

  • Amanda

    I would buy them, they are neat, but the fact it’s a live animal — i would only buy to release.  

    Next it will be embryos!  There is no justice for life — not American, Asian, or any.  

    This is just another thing to fuel hatred!

  • Thoradam

     Who The Heck Would Even Think Of Doing This! This Is Just Awful!

  • Animal Cruelty is Disgusting

    this disgusts me so much that i have made posters to put up around my school and prepared a speech for the next assembly. i can’t believe that people would do this to the poor things. also Asians do eat puppies they also eat fully grown dogs and horses. i should know because when i was 3 i lived in Asia. you would think that people would take some action sooner and get it made illegal. this is extremely disgusting and anybody actually buys them for the reasons intended are too.

  • Animal Cruelty is Disgusting

    also stop getting off topic your meant to be talking about the poor animals

  • Gus

    just to chime in here but you’re horribly desensitized to cultural differences. many people all over the world eat dogs and cats, and the reason is not that they are bad people, it is because in their culture these animals are not “friends” as they are in our culture. we choose not to eat these animals because we have domesticated them and now consider them our companions, an idea very foreign in asian and many other cultures. stop being a liberal green holistic idiot and start actually learning about the world rather than being a racist assbag

  • http://www.facebook.com/likethemike Michael O’Dell

    Wow. Just wow. How ignorant.

  • http://www.crazypaydayloans.co.uk/ www.crazypaydayloans.co.uk

    Since there is no law preventing the existence of these keychains, so
    there may not be an end to them anytime soon,

  • Someonebetterthanyou

    She’s not racist you uneducated fool. She’s simply as uneducated as you are. It’s called stereotyping, not racism.  And yes this is some truly sick behavior. I could see a SINGLE person doing this but an actual market for it? Holy shit!!

  • Anonymous

    Of course you can’t paint everyone with the same brush, but really…you wouldn’t see those keychains in England or the US. What does that tell you? Its a whole different culture. A chinese person would see a live animal bagged up in a supermarket and not even blink. A westerner would be appauled. Personally I think there are certain lines that shouldn’t be crossed and animals should be treated with respect up until they are dead, and not just as food or entertainment. Its basic decency. 

  • Anonymous

    I wanted to add also that there are all sorts of abuse that go on in any country you go to. I doubt that you’d find any country where the abuse  of animals doesnt exist. Its just that in some places (including western countries) its more concealed. Thats the sad truth unfortunately. Doesn’t mean people should just become desensitized to it though.  

  • Lsmorgonsky

    If i ever come across one, I would cut the bag and put the animal in a proper tank.

  • Z-may

    I’d better sound as a  racist than eat puppies and lock turtles in plastic bags like asians do ! Asians are sometimes  really disgusting

  • Caitlinamandagonzalez

    i would buy 700 and cut the bag then give em away to fish people

  • http://www.facebook.com/ron.askotzky Ron Askotzky

    disgraceful!

  • bob

    Neat! I wish they sold them here in the us of a where I live. :(

  • Maddy

    TURTLES CANT BREATHE IN THE WATER. They need oxygen just like us. This makes me so sad to see. I have four baby turtles kept in large, well heated tanks. Each of them will live to be about 25. By putting them into these tiny closed bags this cuts their life expectancy from 25+ years to maybe a month. Disgusting how people have no regard for animals.

  • Roberto Burgos

    They should shove them in plastic baggies with colored nutrience rich water and see how long they last this is cruelty!!!

  • Tadhine♥

    aww , feel so sad for turtles :(

  • tadhine ♥

    Duh . not all asians !

  • Harman Singh

    India respects life. In fact they do not put down the stray dogs either. Recently they have started to sterilize them as well in order to prevent the rising population. It has been proven in European countries that this is more efficient and costs less than murdering them.

    Don’t lump us all together. Although I agree a large margin of the Chinese are pretty horrible when it comes to animal welfare. They need to be educated but they don’t give a crap. It’s all about the money….those pieces of

  • Kitty

    This is so sick !! Sollution is don´t eat meat – sacrifice maybe for doggie in China or for cow in America or Europe. And when you´ll see this fucking souvenirs buy as many as you can and set them free.
    I would kill everybody who do something to animal :(((

  • Swedish

    This is one of the most hideous things I’ve ever read. How is it these people don’t care for the animals, their thinking and culture needs to be changed fast when it comes to animals welfare!!

  • Rebecca Hewson

    I have never ever ever been so ashamed in humans. Ever. It makes me disgusted to be one. Whoevers idea this was is just the fucking devil.

  • Anonymous

    What’s wrong with eating puppies? For us it sounds disgusting because in our culture they are pets. But what if in their culture chickens and cows are pets, and they’re equally disgusted at the fact that we kill and eat them. Puppies weren’t naturally put on earth by God to be pets.

  • Anonymous

    And in North America people boil lobster alive. In Europe they boil frogs alive. Just the fact that they eat cats and dogs isn’t in itself bad. It’s just not accepted in our culture.

  • Dragua

    I would buy all of them just to let the critters out and into a proper environment.

  • http://www.facebook.com/rich.plamondon Rich Plamondon

    Horrible. Where’s the petition… I’ll sign.

  • Parker264

    IF I ever bought these I would get a tank and suplies and put them in that!
    I have ALWAYS wanted to have a pet turtle!
    IF you think its KINDA “cool” click reply and say yes if you do and what would you do if you bought one of these if no still click respond and say no!
    I’m not saying its cool.It’s actualy VERY CRUEL!!

  • DEB

    this is just SICK wonder if they would like to be bagged

  • jeff

    does anyone know how I can order one of these? ill just cut it open and keep the turtle as a pet

  • jen

    What can you expect. they are finding ways to earn money. Since they have no compassion for living things.. This is a good way for them to earn them.

  • mike

    THIS is just stupid to die a slow death like this is cruel and to be in a bag these people need to live like that put them in their bag of liquid and little air and no real food to eat and see how long they live and there is no such thing a luck and only shows us as how dumb we humans are to things that have been here long before us for we are the parasites to treat living things this was ..I hope they stop it!!!!!!!!

  • Anonymous

    how this turn into eating animals this is about the stupid thing they are doing making live key chains all so brilliant cant even stay on subject…

  • Animallover

    What is wrong with China? I just watched a video yesterday about their fur farms that left me emotionally drained. I was shocked. I’ve seen even more today. What is up with the animal abuse there? Why do they think this is ok?

  • Animallover

    I just watched a video of the Chinese being exposed, ripping the skin off of live dogs, cats, rabbits, and raccoons. They were still alive. There was a dog who had survived the skinning and was screaming in pain and he tried to walk out so they stomped on his neck. And they took him away, and fried him. I really wish I hadn’t seen it because now I am so angry at the Chinese and grow angrier every time I see stuff like this, so please don’t give me your bull shit trying to stand up for them. Hell no. China is a fucked up country.

  • Mark

    Let us not forget the real issue here, since the discussion has deviated from animal rights to racism.

  • http://www.facebook.com/chris.ryuk.5 Chris Ryuk

    where can I sign against this?

  • Tiki Roommate

    I find it interesting when people are quick to attribute something horrible like this as being innate to a specific group of people when more than anything else, it’s the “hunger” for profit and exploitation inherent in human beings. In this case, it just happens to be in China, where the impact of globalization has left their society in a rat race on steroids. More than anything else, it makes me appreciative of the early 20th-century muckrakers who helped fight for regulation in our society to prevent garment factories from burning down with hundreds trapped within or the selling of human and rat meat in our food. The difference between us and them is we have a system of government that allowed for people to create a more perfect society (by means of regulation).

  • Martha Iveth Garcia

    What is wrong with these people, come on they are living creatures. Animal torture is not fashion !!!!, this is awflu.

  • Rap Attack

    How sick is this…we are indeed the most sick species on this planet….evil

  • http://www.facebook.com/RichieNga Richie Nga

    I’m an Asian and I dare you to come to Malaysia to eat a puppy and see if the crowd would lynch you to death for doing so. Fucking racist !

    And the same goes for all the morons who thinks all Asians are the same !

  • http://www.facebook.com/amberfall.2 Amber Fall

    Can’t even begin to wonder how they feel trapped inside those tiny bags :( absolutely disgusting

  • http://www.facebook.com/selma.brkic.98 Brkic Selma

    ala -.-

  • A. Nix

    This yellow fucking People.They are Sick

  • http://www.facebook.com/emily.mauro.1 Emily Mauro

    this is just crule if i was at china and if i was rich i would buy so many of them and start a amphibian/reptile zoo

  • http://www.facebook.com/emily.mauro.1 Emily Mauro

    in america

  • http://twitter.com/EricsBizTweets EricsBizTweets

    how horrible

  • j19p83

    I feel that I need to raise a few points regarding this long and complicated argument.
    1) I think it is safe to say that Melissa was referring to Chinese people in her initial statement and if you read her statement properly she likens the treatment of animals in Asia to their treatment in America.

    2) The idea that eating a dog that has been beaten to death is comparable to a chicken that is killed quickly by having it’s throat cut is ridiculous.

    3) Dogs and cats are animals that not only interact with humans but have been shown to aid in the identification of disease, aid treatment and in many cases save lives (eg. war dogs) they therefore are not viewed by the majority of the world to be part of the food chain.

    4) Female circumcision is part of the culture in certain African cultures, does that mean it is acceptable that girls are being mutilated? The ‘it’s their culture’ argument can only ever hold so much water.

    5) Do a little search on google and have a look at which country tops the lists of animal cruelty, while you are there have a look and see how many countries in this day and age have no animal protection laws…….

    Please people rather than jumping on the PC bandwagon and labelling people as racist read their statement properly and do a little research.

  • dontcallmehuman

    It’s awful that this is going on but no worse than goldfish in bags in western countries. Also, unless you don’t eat meat, you have no right to comment on which animals its right or wrong to slaughter. Just admit that all meat is wrong but we don’t care enough to stop eating it because it’s tasty. So yes, it’s terrible this is happening, but anyone using this as an excuse to be racist is a fucking idiot. Some people just want to blame anyone who’s different at any opportunity they can.

  • Ted Johnson

    China has people that care about animals too, but over several decades of Communist rule, you learned to keep your mouth shut. However, in their new found economic success, I hope there are more Chinese like Mary Peng, to fight for the welfare of animals, and the fact that people were buying the amulets to free the animals show that many Chinese have hearts just like many in the west, to the needless suffering of animals. I don’t like the way dogs and cats are treated in China, but look at the way chickens and cows are treated on American corporate farms and tell me that we are any different. MORE POWER TO MARY PENG to make a difference in China!!!

  • Jugier

    This is yet another sick story that we hear, what the hell is the matter with these people. Disgusting!

  • James

    Fact is animal cruelty exists in every nation and the whole world needs to wake up and do something about it. It’s also a fact though that the Chinese are the world leaders in animal cruelty. They turn my stomach

  • Ogbin

    Put a stop to this, anything to make a buck. Sick

  • Miguel

    Inventaron el TAMAGOCHI y dijeron que era una ridículo, pero
    si les parece plausible esta aberración!!! Son totalmente enfermos.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1340869056 Wendy Z. Mdza

    Is Chinese ppl mentally retarted or what? This just so sad!! It’s not even cool!

  • Sorry Turtle

    Um, are you Asian? They eat puppies.

  • Sorry Turtle

    I mean, we’re predators, so I’m not really big on making minor distinctions… but dogs have the mental capacity of school aged children. They are a symbiotic species to humans. We evolved with them. Human evolution was changed by our interactions with dogs. They are a social predator species. We’re suppose to eat cows n stuff. They’re prey. Dogs- no. It’s not natural!

  • Sorry Turtle

    or nature. don’t forget it isn’t accepted in nature, either. stringy, lean predators don’t make great food. Give me a break.

  • Sorry Turtle

    People who deliberately stop critically thinking once they reach the “oh, their CULTURE is different… ohhh…” realization don’t need to be lecturing anyone on getting edumacated. Please. A non American said “They DO skin and eat cats and dogs in Asia.” your response was completely non-factual, poorly thought out, and irrelevant. Please. Go to school.

  • Sorry Turtle

    It’s socially acceptable in Asia to eat puppies. Not every American is a gun owner, either, and our country is severely divided about gun ownership… I don’t go on chat rooms and call people jerks for pointing out that in America, owning a gun is common and accepted, just because HALF OUR COUNTRY opposes it. It doesn’t change facts, ya know? Asians eat puppies. But not Nicole, everyone! Not Nicole. Happy?

  • Sorry Turtle

    Yeah. There aren’t like. a TON of animal cruelty laws on the books or anything. Jeez. Stop watching PETA propaganda- we know for a fact they killed more animals more maliciously and deceptively than any of the slaughterhouses they video taped.

    What you are saying is like saying Americans have the same misogyny problems as countries that openly an unapologetically oppress women because, uh, look what Ted Bundy did. Individual assholes breaking laws at individual slaughterhouses do not compare to cultures who skin pets alive because, well, that’s how they were raised. Not the same thing.

  • Peter

    fuck i’m shaking.. this is so horrible

  • holy crap

    Why does everything turn into a racist debate? This is about animals being put in a sealed plastic bag with no oxygen. I have eaten a lot of different foods and if I didn’t have a choice I’d eat a dog, but I do have a choice, so I don’t. Same thing here. We all have a choice. Just don’t buy them and don’t fuel it with bringing in things that aren’t relevant like racist comments. Out of curiosity, how many of you would buy one if it wasn’t harmful?

  • http://www.facebook.com/alexander.moor.562 Alexander Moor

    where can i buy this fishes?

  • Anonymous

    i think you missed the white race, which was the first to invade america and caused mayhem and destruction among native population.

  • http://www.facebook.com/grace.carrin Grace Carrin

    Well whether Melissa is or not a vegan – I AM and also very appalled by this and a lot of things most people do to animals. But I’m sorry in China, they DO do horrendous things in the preparation of animals. They also eat things prepared in strange ways to promote their sexual prowess – a hell of a reason to do some of the things they do. This keychain thing is just plain ludicrous and inhumane. It is totally unnecessary to do this, that’s what is the most appalling of all. To torture an animal for a keychain!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/grace.carrin Grace Carrin

    It should not be accepted in any culture but your analogy is a little off the mark. Lobsters are not tortured for weeks before they are killed. And I don’t agree with eating lobster but it is put in the pot head first usually which is supposed to deaden the nerves. I’m not an expert but I think the lobster dies pretty quickly. They are not tortured before hand. It’s not a matter of acceptance its a matter of humanity. To throw live animal in boiling water, to skin them alive – these are all done in China. I am a vegan and to me all killing is wrong but torturing makes it worse.

  • http://www.facebook.com/grace.carrin Grace Carrin

    Hopefully if there are enough people screaming about things – some things will change. All of you who think this is horrendous, look at your life and see what you do to torture animals. If you are not vegan, you are in some way responsible for the torture and death of another living being.

  • http://www.facebook.com/grace.carrin Grace Carrin

    I have to say here about animal testing – a lot of testing on animals has stopped here in America. But if we want to trade with China they want animal testing even though it has been proven that it does not work. The makeup companies have been told by the Chinese government that animal testing must be done. You can check on that. Mary Kay,Estee Lauder, Avon, among others have been told by the Chinese government that if they want their products in China they must go back to animal testing. And they are doing it!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/lisa.straus.3 Lisa Straus

    yes it is

  • http://www.facebook.com/lisa.straus.3 Lisa Straus

    I think the people that make these should be shoved in a bag .

  • CHEN

    Actually melissa, I JUST ARRIVED AFTER FEW MONTHS IN CHINA, PUPPIES, CATS AND OTHER BEAUTIFUL ANIMALS ARE BEING BROUGHT TO A SLAUGHTER OUSE IN TRUCKS…AWEFUL.

  • http://twitter.com/filmandmusic filmandmusic

    Only in China….

  • kreamofsumyounguy

    Asians (we) are more accurately portrayed by the above post than yours Melissa. While the prior comment was not totally true, yours is totally ignorant.

  • Jenkinz

    asians? so also taiwanese, japanese, korean??? lol

  • G

    These people have gone mad. No way in hell that this is created by a human with any normal thinking behaviour. This should be stopped immediately. What kind of world is this when we allow mentally ill people do ill things?

  • G

    it not about just getting to eat it, its about suffering.

  • http://www.facebook.com/kidjr27 Jvan Azia

    This is beyond UNACCEPTABLE and I will NOT stand for it!!! People, we have watched God’s beloved creatures get tortured, enslaved, and slaughtered, for many many years and we have done nothing to stop it. It’s sad to think about obesity on one side and starving children on the other side, wouldn’t you agree? There is something wrong with that picture as we can all clearly see.

    I’m not even about to begin to start giving details of the cruelty being done to farm animals as well as domestic and wild but, I will tell you a little bit of what the Bible says about how we should treat ALL animals/creatures.

    The Bible commands us to take care of the animals under our care. One
    of the signs of a righteous man, the Bible says, is that he takes care
    of his animals (see Proverbs 12:10). Even the animal of an enemy was to
    be treated kindly: “If you come across your enemy’s ox or donkey
    wandering off, be sure to take it back to him” (Exodus 23:4). One reason
    God commanded His people to rest one day out of seven was so their
    animals would be refreshed (see Exodus 23:12).

    In fact, the Bible
    says we must never treat any part of God’s creation with contempt. When
    we do, we are indirectly treating our Creator with contempt. Instead,
    God calls us to be stewards or trustees of His creation, and the Bible
    reminds us that we are responsible to Him for the way we treat it. We’ve
    often forgotten this — but it’s still true, and when we ignore it we
    not only hurt God’s creation but we also hurt ourselves.

    Most of
    all, however, God calls us to put Him first in our lives. He loves us,
    and our greatest calling is to respond to His love by opening our hearts
    and lives to His Son, Jesus Christ.

  • bob

    One phrase that can sum up the absolute degeneration of humanity….”made in China.”

  • hcote

    the buyers are just as sick minded as the sellers

  • Kat

    I don’t know if this had been said already but if anyone actually sees these, you should NEVER buy them to release them.

    I would be so heartbroken if I saw this, but if you buy them just to release the animals, you’re just lining their pockets and allowing the trade to continue.

    I guess stealing a massive load would be a lot better but possibly against the law

    DON’T BUY THEM EVEN TO RELEASE THEM :/

  • raad

    keeping in a aquarium is more better than alive keychains

  • Rosalind Alexander

    I would go to China, specifically to punch the vendors (oh and I’m not a violent person).

  • olguita2012

    Criminal!!! No respect for life. They should be prohibited and punish the inventors.

  • sky

    This is so wrong. What did the turtles or the other animals ever do to be treated this way. This makes me sick to my stomach to think people on the same planet as me are treating animals in this manner. People really need to put an end to this.