comScore
Uncategorized Thursday, October 13th 2011 at 3:10 pm

Good Television That Is Being Threatened From the Inside

Every year, there are a dozen or so shows on television that are cancelled or never make it to the point where they are even given the green light to begin. It’s more often that pilots are picked up and dumped after a few episodes than just about anything else. It is just the nature of the game.

Less frequently, an already established show teeters on the edge for one reason or another. Something has gone wrong and the show nears the brink for a combination of reasons, but typically with one main driving force behind them. It is unusual for more than a handful of shows to be so close to the abyss.

Now, that’s not to say that all of these shows will be cancelled, but merely that there are a number of factors in play that could significantly threaten them. We at Geekosystem present, a list of good television shows that are threatened by their own decisions.

1. House Cast

As time has gone on, Fox’s best-known medical drama, House, has had a rotating cast of characters with some but not too many regulars. This season, there are even fewer regulars than normal. For a drama of this kind, especially one named after a central character, House, M.D. has almost been around for too long. All of the normal character arcs have played their hands long ago and now we’re back to introducing new faces in order to produce new arcs.

But this season marks the absence of Lisa Edelstein, Dr. Lisa Cuddy, as she and Hugh Laurie’s House had a falling out at the end of last season. It’s been written off as Cuddy leaving for another position somewhere else, and she’s gone from regularly appearing. In addition to this, Olivia Wilde has been off making movies and thus appears irregularly as Thirteen. Oh, and did I mention there are two new doctors, both female, being added to the squad? Taub is soon to be outnumbered. But the point remains: This is an obvious attempt to reinvigorate a show that has already had its time and done what it set out to do. It may or it may not actually do it.

2. The Walking Dead Loses Director

If there’s one major upset from the summer that left a sour taste in everyone’s mouth, it was the way Frank Darabont was let go from The Walking Dead. Even at Comic-Con in July, days before the announcement, Mr. Darabont was earnestly selling the show to hundreds of fans. It’s safe to say that it came as quite a shock to the man.

But what’s more shocking is how this speaks to the underlying current in AMC original programming. With the recent issues with both Mad Men and Breaking Bad, The Walking Dead is in good company. The network is butting heads with all of their creators, it seems, and that’s not for the best on our end of the spectrum.

3. Paying for The Simpsons

The Simpsons is one of the most successful cartoons ever created. If we limit that further to cartoons for television, the gap between it and what would be its competitors widens even further. But that doesn’t mean everyone’s happy with The Simpsons. From fans to Fox and its parent company, everyone seems to have a bone to pick.

Ignoring the fact that a good many folks seem to believe that anything past the 8th season or so is garbage, the network just recently insisted that the principal voice actors take a major pay cut in order to keep The Simpsons on the air. Granted, tense salary negotiations are par for the course when it comes to television, but if the media is at all close to the mark, then The Simpsons may only have two more seasons before Fox pulls the plug indefinitely.

4. South Park’s Ennui

Say what you want about South Park, but the show manages to stay current and has provided some insightful comment over the years. But that’s not a pace that anyone can maintain for long and it’s beginning to show. The creators, Trey Parker and Matt Stone, have become disillusioned with their own particular brand of mockery that they helped make popular.

Usually, in this situation, this kind of disillusionment would result in the writers being replaced or something of that nature. Instead, Parker and Stone have decided to seemingly work it out through their main outlet: The show itself. This season, Stan suddenly begins to see everything he once loved as shit and says that he can’t go on any longer. This is reminiscent of his creators’ plight as they are under contract to produce more episodes of the show.

5. Every Show Ever on SyFy

This might first sound like hyperbole and then like a joke, or the other way around, but it is unfortunately a completely serious entrant on this list. Even before Comcast merged with NBC Universal, shows had been dropping like flies. Caprica, Stargate Universe and now Eureka have all been cancelled in just under a year.

What makes this even more shocking is that it’s not like Eureka wasn’t a popular franchise; it just wasn’t profitable enough. The profit margins weren’t high enough for SyFy’s parent company. This is where alarm bells should be ringing, given that science fiction television is rarely cheap to make and Eureka has a large enough fan base to ratings margin to have a regular cast of rotating geek icon cameos, including Felicia Day and Wil Wheaton.

They see me, Rollin

Filed Under |
  • http://twitter.com/sledge149 Jimmy Sledge

    Just not profitable enough.  “Enough”  What goes through the minds of TV execs? @syfy #saveeureka

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_LV3NLEZA5W2MY7CXQVODC5XDCQ N8

    Now theres two comments, just goes to show how critical this article is. thanks stumble…. thumbs down, lets try this again. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Smav-Martin/100000265867594 Smav Martin

    This would probably matter more if I watched ANY of these shows or cared about that. I stopped caring about Scifi as soon as it changed its name. Their shows were shitty around that time and still are.

  • Malforian

    House needs more Wilson! its at its best with those two together

  • Asreal

    Still can’t believe they canned Caprica; it was brilliant… =/

  • Anonymous

    They cancelled EUReKA……….???? WTF is wrong with America these days — it didn’t earn enough revenue. It seems that the almighty dollar has replaced these moron’s souls!!!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VNB5YVKX6DTITCPDKHTLMVJGIA Deb

    SyFy needs to change their Imagine Greater.  Because they have no Imagination or Loyality.  They sure don’t care about those who love and watch these shows they are cancelling.  Yes I am still very UPSET about the cancellation of StarGate Universe.  What Idiots……..

  • Jasajunk

    Troll

  • http://twitter.com/rollinbishop Rollin Bishop

    Human being. I can only assume. (The avatar seems to indicate this, anyhow.)

  • Tom Triumph

    Eureka might make a profit,but SyFy must think it can make more in the same slot.  That means:

    a) There are too many people at SyFy headquarters “strategizing” and their collective salaries eat up those Eureka profits, so they have to think up ways to increase the revenue stream even more.

    b) They want a show with merchandise–action figures and the like…  Or that “men” like, like they did at their old job on Spike TV….

    c) Which causes them to make bad decisions about what their demographics want, because they don’t know what their demographic wants and disregard the best indicator–ratings and profits.

    d) In turn, this justifies their positions.  If it’s a hit, it’s their doing.  A flop, and you need some experts to fix it.  Win-win (for them).

    e) Someone might realize that if they cut the suit payroll at SyFy headquarters the parent company could just let the Eurekas trundle on and collect a check each week with no drama; a steady revenue stream until a must-produce product comes down the pipe or it falls into the read.

    It won’t happen.  Eureka: RIP.