comScore
Entertainment Monday, February 4th 2013 at 12:30 pm

HBO Tells Google to Remove Links to HBO Because the DMCA is the Worst

By ( ) Comments

We never tire of these stories, because they constantly remind us all how stupid and pointless automated Digital Millennium Copyright Act takedown requests are. HBO has filed a request with Google demanding that they remove links to — you guessed it — HBO’s own website, because they say they are violating their own copyrights. The request demands that links to other legitimate sites be removed as well, because again, automated DMCA takedown requests are the worst.

The request was made on behalf of HBO by a company called DtectNet, which is the anti-piracy arm of MarkMonitor. It asked Google to remove links to the Eastbound and Down section of HBO’s online store, but it wasn’t just their own site they were after. HBO also demanded that links from MTV.com, IGN.com, and Pinterest be removed. None of the links to these sites had any content that violated copyright laws, and were just news stories and reviews of HBO content.

Google managed to realize that these requests were bogus before it actually removed any links, but the likelihood that they’ll be able to keep pace with the deluge of invalid DMCA orders is slim. Companies like DtectNet show no signs of slowing down with this garbage. Last year there were 50 million DMCA takedown requests sent to companies like Google demanding content be removed, and as we’ve already seen, that often includes legitimate sites.

Thankfully, it also often includes companies that are abusing the DMCA asking Google to take down their own content, because it’s the only silver lining to this ridiculous, ridiculous situation. If companies are going to be stupid and irresponsible with laws like the DMCA, at least we get to laugh at them for doing so.

Can we please start fining companies that send bogus DMCA requests?

(via TorrentFreak, image via Drumaboy)

Relevant to your interests

Filed Under | • • • • • •
  • John

    I am confused … what is the advantage or strategy of these DMCA requests?

  • Anonymous

    To cause mass havoc amongst companies on the Internet, as well as in the courts… DMCA is supposed to be for everybody’s good, right? I don’t think so.

  • Phil

    Isn’t “DtechNet” violating “Google” trademark by also using it? Opps, I violated 2. Well atleast for me they can’t get blood from a rock. They will have to wait til the economy gets better!!

  • Anonymous

    There should be a financial penatly imposed on false DMCA request notices.
    Currently, anyone can set up a bot for pennies that simply sends DMCA takedown requests for any and all pages on the internet – causing enormous costs for the content hosters just to process these letters (let alone talk about missing revenue on part of the addressed content creators or owners who actually do not infrigre on the copyright). Thus the current process can also be used as an effective tool to drive out comptetitors from the market, by forcing them to do nothing else all day but to process or counter-file on bogus takedown requests.

  • Ribbed for her pleasure

    A form of ‘Denial of service’ from fake takedown requests?

  • Manish Sinha

    i think that they have to case on DMCA…
    Because DMCA Also removes his own contents if he posting some parts of his contents like some images then DMCA will removed automatically.and say these terms are violating our TOS.

    i think some strict action need to take against DMCA.