comScore
Uncategorized Wednesday, November 24th 2010 at 12:54 pm

Mark Wahlberg to Star in Uncharted and How Hollywood Should’ve Done It

We knew Nathan Fillion barely had a chance to be cast as Nathan Drake in the upcoming film adaptation of the stellar Uncharted video game series, even more so when David O. Russell was said to be the writer and director due to his penchant for Mark Wahlberg movies. Well, over on MTV Multiplayer, Mark Wahlberg confirmed that he’ll be playing Nathan Drake in the Uncharted film, showing that, once again, Hollywood doesn’t know what it’s doing regarding beloved video game franchises and obvious casting.

Aside from casting Mark Wahlberg instead of probably even thinking about Nathan Fillion, David O. Russell is writing parts in the script for Joe Pesci and Robert De Niro and hopes to bring the two together as Nathan Drake’s uncle and father, two characters that don’t exist in the two Uncharted games. Next, I’m sure we’ll find out that either Elena Fisher isn’t in the movie as Drake’s love interest, or she will be and they won’t cast Emily Rose, who does Elena’s voice acting in the games and looks just like her in real life. Let’s get Julia Roberts instead!

Listen, Hollywood, if there ever was an easy film adaptation of anything, it’s Uncharted. Here’s why:

1. It’s the easiest casting ever.

Nathan Fillion as Nathan Drake

Bruce Campbell as Sully

Emily Rose as Elena Fisher

Uncharted: Drake’s Fortune boxart comparison with mocked-up Nathan Fillion boxart


2. Not only do the actors look just like the characters, but they act just like the characters.

  • Nathan Drake is a charming, handsome, fun, sarcastic, victim of both extremes of luck, loyal thief with a heart of gold. Nathan Fillion is best known for his role as Malcolm Reynolds on Firefly, a charming, handsome, fun, sarcastic, victim of both extremes of luck, loyal space thief with a heart of gold.
  • Victor Sullivan is a wise, wise-cracking, loyal, “too old for this” partner-in-crime to Nathan Drake. Bruce Campbell’s current role on the popular television show Burn Notice, Sam Axe, is a wise, wise-cracking, loyal, “too old for this” partner-in-crime to the show’s main character, Michael Weston.
  • Elena Fisher, Drake’s love interest, is a sassy, witty, no-nonsense, caring, can-take-care-of-herself journalist. On SyFy’s Haven, Emily Rose plays Audrey Parker, a sassy, witty, no-nonsense, caring, can-take-care-of-herself detective.

3. Nathan Fillion really, really wants to be Nathan Drake.

Aside from Fillion fitting the role of Nathan Drake better than anyone in the entirety of human existence, he really wants to play Nathan Drake. I mean, really really. He launched a Twitter campaign where he asked his followers to help get him the role. Having your lead actor love and relish his role can only bring good things for a movie and said actor’s performance.

4. Everyone else really, really wants Nathan Fillion to be Nathan Drake.

Starting off your movie by pissing off the franchise’s loyal fan base is not a great way to start a movie, a sentiment we even ranted about a few days ago! Just google “nathan fillion uncharted” or “nathan fillion nathan drake” and you’ll see what I mean.

5. The Uncharted games are the closest gaming has ever come to “playing a movie.”

This is because Uncharted feels just like a summer blockbuster, from the witty writing, to the deep character development, to the gunfights, to the explosions, to the plot twists, to the last-second lucky escapes from death, Uncharted feels more like a movie than a lot of movies do. As for the script? All David O. Russell would have to do essentially, is copy/paste the first game’s script into whatever script-writing program he uses, then format the sequences where the player is in control into scripted sequences for the film. Easy peasy.

6. Nathan Drake and Nathan Fillion are both Nathans.

It’s destiny.

Listen, Mark Wahlberg is a fine actor, but his acting style that he’s displayed in nearly every single movie in which he’s starred simply doesn’t resemble anything that makes Nathan Drake worthwhile, and if David O. Russell manages to land Joe Pesci and Robert De Niro, the same goes for them.

So far, all I can do is sit and brood, probably along with most of the other Uncharted fans, and pray that the movie doesn’t end up as disappointing as it is already beginning to sound.

(story via MTV Multiplayer; some pictures via PS3 Informer)

Filed Under |
  • Charliewilcher

    Yeah, I think Hollywood real F’d up this time.

  • Nickjdavila

    The funny thing is even before I knew about people screaming for Nathan Fillion I used to play the game and wish for the same cast you just said. Hollywood is filled with a bunch of idiots the director and writer of this movie did not have to do abything except for be at the set the movie was made before the idiots jumped on ship.

  • Anonymous

    I’m with you on this. It’s still bothering me.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Collin-McGuire/100001321535612 Collin McGuire

    dude i cant believe nathan fillion didnt get the role but robert dinero wouldve been a better sully

  • Jmalb42

    Great cast ideas. WHy can’t we ever win?

    This kind of Hollywood thinking os what makes me worry about the Dark Tower movies…

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1218104779 Kim Giele

    This is exactly the cast I had in mind! I’m so pissed of they chose Mark Wahlberg!! Bruce Campbell has a kind of quality just like Sully, the same goes for Nathan Fillion as Nathan Drake…

  • Vvh4mster1987

    Every word that was said in this was 100% correct. Uncharted is an amazing story and no one would fit the role better than nathan fillion.. Its so bull and I’m not going to, watch it cause its gonna suck. Hands down.. Way to fuck up an easy one hollywood.. Waste money on something that could have been amazing. I PRAY they read this and cat that exact line up cause honestly, the work is done for them.

  • Ant

    I think Bradley Cooper could play the best Drake if he’d cut his hair

  • seid

    emily rose would be perfect including the fact she voices elena fisher lol.

  • Acense

    You’re absolutely right.Fillion would be a perfect Drake. Mark is an ok actor, but his style has nothing to do with what “Uncharted” is all about. Frankly I’m not surprised; Hollywood always finds a way of turning great games into terrible movies. I’m not falling for this one.

  • Kwhyee

    This is almost as disturbing as Jamie Foxx playing Lynch in the Kane & Lynch movie. Thats so out of place that it no sense at all

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4XF3LF5LHTZGGRIG46DUX6AE2Y -Rane

    Could *not* agree with you more! Nathan Fillion *is* Nathan Drake…considering anyone else is just stupid. I seriously hope they do the right, and smart, thing and cast Fillion! :)

  • darthwhit

    How do you ruin a no brainer like Max Payne and then get a shot to ruin Uncharted.  The very reason video game movies aren’t good cause the casting sucks.  Yet Angelina Jolie was perfect for Tomb Raider and yet they still were not great.

  • lyndee perry

    man i really wanted nathan fillion to pay nathan drake he fits him perfectly, but we just have to be happy wit matt w. i heard hes a good actor, at first i thought this is gonna be horrible movie cause i thought he was a bad actor. the only movie i have seen him in was the happening and i heard he regreted that he went into the movie or sometin like that so i hope he does good

  • Lyndee perry

    nathan fillion is also very funny in castle lol and i luved the movie serenity it was awesome :]

  • Jackdexx

    bradley cooper should be drake. he can act the part. big name for the film. he is a lot like him.    watch the a-team, and you will know copper is the best bet for drake.

  • http://www.facebook.com/emmanuel.alamo Emmanuel Alamo

    Yeah Dude I agree if they arent going to use Nathan Fillion and on top of that add some fucked up storyline the might as well not make the film at all. Its like they say…… You cant fix what aint broke.

  • Mahusanif

    Oh dear, hollywood fucked up another awesome game. Didn’t see that one coming. But seriously, they don’t care how the film turns out. They just get the money when the insane amount of people turn up to watch it

  • Jeremyg25

    seriously, BOTH of them dont deserve the part. This movie shouldnt even be made cause it IS a movie. NOLAN NORTH should be Drake cause Drake IS NOLAN NORTH

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jered-Lacks/1128197292 Jered Lacks

    Mark Wahlberg is a lame choice to play Nathan Drake. He will act like plain old Wahlberg with a scowl on his face. Nathan Drake’s character is too happy -go- lucky to be played by Mark Wahlberg. Nathan Fillion is a good choice. I also thought that Josh Duhamel or Joseph Gordon Levitt would be good for the part of Nathan Drake. I love the idea of Bruce Campbell being Sully (he fits the role perfectly). 

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jered-Lacks/1128197292 Jered Lacks

    I wouldn’t mind seeing Bradly Cooper as Drake.

  • MicHaeL

    Oh man, I agree EXACTLY to about all of this.
    I’m only glad that someone sees it and put it out there.
    Too bad things are still messing up though…

    Maybe ANOTHER campaign? “Nathan for Nathan!”?

  • Chavezangelo82

    If you want some one to play as drake then cast nick lashey as him from 98 degrees!!

  • Philg

    I have nothing against Marky Mark, but I think we’ve seen enough of him in movies.
    He doesn’t fit at all in the role of Nathan Drake. Didn’t they learn anything with the failure of the Max Payne movie?
    Hollywood shows again that it’s become a clique of accountants.
    No wonder all Hollywood movies are cr*p these days.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1281687943 Mike Moon

    OMG this was a no brainer. There goes another game to movie adaptation down the drains. How could they be so stupid. They don’t know crap about movies and how to please the audience. Marky Mark? He doesn’t look anything like Nathan Drake. It’s obvious he was inspired by Nathan Fillion…

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1281687943 Mike Moon

    Not watching this… nope.

  • Gabz

    Nolan North is Nathan Drake.. nuff said

  • MicHaeL

    I’m sorry, I have to disagree to that. Nolan North definitely is the soul of the character, of course he made the character live apart from the work of the other artists on the game.
    BUT, he does not look quite like Nathan Drake enough. That’s why I’d vote for Nathan Fillion as the live-action visual actor, in whom I also trust to be able to also live up to what Nolan North did for the games.
    It’s important that the actor also LOOKS right, and if Nolan North looked enough like Nathan Drake then all the better, it’s painful enough to say that the original actor, unfortunately, doesn’t.
    But I’m sure that Nathan Fillion would respect his performances and the character enough to live up to it, also having the talent and the right charisma.

  • Talbot

    They should play that one chick from Clash of the Titans, she was the princess in Prince of Persia, as chloe. I think she resembles her enough. What do you guys think?

  • Yadiel1780

    Its better that the guy that does hawkeye make nathan drake character