comScore
Uncategorized Wednesday, October 5th 2011 at 2:40 pm

Most Disappointing Upgrades in Tech

If there’s one thing we can be sure of in this world, it’s that companies will generally release an upgrade for their primary gadget or software if the original was well-received. This can range from the minor upgrade to the spiritual sequel or even an entirely new endeavor with the old name slapped on. There will always be those riding the coattails of their former achievements, but there are also those companies who seem to be genuinely trying to improve their product and just miss the mark. Whether it’s a matter of public perception, a number of times they fall short of their goal, or a combination of factors.

Both of these can lead to disappointing results — financially and otherwise — that can leave the general public jaded. So, here at last is our list of the most disappointing technology upgrades and additions.

1. Windows Vista

Windows Vista is a mess of an operating system. It was touted as the upgrade that would finally bring Windows to those who love Macs. The long-awaited successor to Windows XP came, then flopped in the worst way. And even that is likely being kind.

If you name a type of problem you could potentially have with a software release, chances are you’ll find someone who had that problem with Windows Vista. Be it security issues, hardware compatibility problems, usability or installation, someone had a problem of that kind with Vista. There was even evidence that Microsoft purposefully lowered the minimum specifications at the request of hardware manufacturers.

2. Sega Saturn

The Sega Saturn will likely go down in history as one of gaming’s biggest blunders. That’s not because it was a poor system in terms of hardware or even because the quirkiness of said hardware made developing software more difficult than for competing consoles; it’s because of the horrible decision to have a fake release day.

The Sega Saturn was to be officially released in the fall of 1995. This was what the world outside of Sega knew to be the date it would become available to the general public. It made sense as it would be just before Sony’s PlayStation would hit the market, but it was not to be. At the first Electronic Entertainment Expo, Sega revealed that the release in the fall was a ruse and that the Sega Saturn was available starting immediately. This came as a surprise to most retailers, third-party developers, and Sega fans alike. It would be only a few short years after this that the Sega Saturn would officially cease production.

3. Ubuntu

Before those of you out there who are diehard Linux fans write this list off entirely, let me explain.

The reason we’ve included Ubuntu, one of the most popular versions of the Linux operation system, on this list is simple and easy to relate: It was meant to be a sort of “Linux for the masses” that still has yet to catch on with said masses and only remains popular in niche segments.

They’ve been trying for years to make it more user friendly, and appeal to those outside of the already devoted Linux crowd. Even with the low price of free and support from companies like IBM, it just hasn’t happened yet. With the way tech moves from new to obsolete, it’s possible that Ubuntu’s potential has been wasted.

4. iPhone 4S

The hardware update for the iPhone 4, the iPhone 4S, is nothing to snort at. It’ll have all new guts that include a processor from the iPad, and the camera is being upgraded on top of that. The software is going to get upgraded as well. Essentially, it’s a brand new iPhone.

Except it’s not branded that way, so therefore it isn’t actually a new iPhone. It’s just an update to the previous iPhone and that’s the rub for so many of the Apple zealots. That’s what’s disappointing: That an update was announced and not an entirely new iPhone. It’s even caused Apple’s stock to drop a wee bit.

5. DIVX


Anyone that sees this might immediately assume that we mean the video codec. We don’t; there was actually an offshoot of the DVD format called DIVX while the codec is DivX. Capitalization makes all the difference. In fact, your first introduction to the thing might have been through Penny Arcade’s character.

DIVX was a horrible format that essentially had the customer purchase a DIVX-enabled DVD player, buy physical copies of movies for around $4 that they could then watch for 24 hours and then had them pay another fee to “rent” their physical media again if they wanted to watch after the initial 24 hour period. If this sounds pretty stupid to you, it’s probably because it was.

It’s also telling that this was a venture backed by Circuit City.

6. Nintendo DSi XL

The biggest disappointment about the launch of the Nintendo DSi XL was that the Nintendo 3DS was announced just prior. The reveal meant that many who might have previously purchased the new update to the Nintendo DSi instead skipped it in favor of eventually purchasing the Nintendo 3DS.

This particular circumstance doesn’t make sense from an economic standpoint, but the rumor is that Nintendo was forced to reveal the 3DS prior to when they would have liked to do so because they knew that the Internet had their hands on the information and would reveal it soon anyway. By revealing it themselves, they saved some face but unintentionally doomed the Nintendo DSi XL.

They see me, Rollin

Filed Under |
  • http://www.facebook.com/sarah.maple Sarah Maple

    Panning Ubuntu makes Sarah cry. :(

  • http://twitter.com/rollinbishop Rollin Bishop

    It is an inconvenient truth.

  • Anonymous

    I still have a VHS tape Sega mailed to me that was promoted the Saturn before its release. I also still have my Saturn. The memory doesn’t work anymore for some reason, so if you play a game, you better plan on beating it that sitting.

  • http://www.traeblain.com/ traeblain

    The reason Ubuntu hasn’t worked for the masses is that the development as a whole spends too much time on aesthetics and not on hardware compatibility. ndiswrapper was one of the greatest features that hit Linux allowing pre-built drivers to run in Linux and in most cases run solidly. Things like this where people wouldn’t have to worry about whether or not their (insert hardware here) will work is how to gain wide spread adoption. Gnome on its own is already user friendly enough to work well. Fighting to get compositing, Ubuntu One, Unity interface, Social integration, and more into the base system is unnecessary. That and the way too frequent update schedule. Having a new version 6 months later scares people. Start with a solid base and keep it secure and working well and 18-24 months later have a good upgrade. And I’m someone that uses Ubuntu daily and is really rooting for it.

    *off my soapbox*

  • http://opinadorcompulsivo.blogspot.com Miquel Mayol i Tur

    Ubuntu has not more installations becasuse they did not find a hardware vendor or make it themselves to sell Ubuntu powered machines.

    Android or Chrome OS that come preinstalled are having a good sucess, but the day Ubuntu for ARM make an easy Android Market App to install Ubuntu with Unity in tablets ou will see a lot of android tablets running Ubuntu and al its GNU programs.

  • Anonymous

    An unfortunate but realistic assessment. 

  • Huh?

    Don’t be fooled!… Windows Vista’s structure was the introduction of “Cloud Computing” (.html, .xml, etc.)  Everybody loves Windows 7, though!

    (Isn’t DIVX the same as .AVI, which we use to make DVDs or use with a player that supports this format? huh? hmm? what?)

  • Rikard

    What’s wrong with Ubuntu? Been using it for 5 years now, and I love it! Turned my back on Windows & OSX for good for sure.

  • Like a som-boo-dee.

    Are you sure? I have a Windows 7 Home PremiumK and home and it has been a year since we bought it. It screws around with us. Windows has devloped so much “security” systems that i cant even get the latest songs without going through about 5 programs clicking “Allow”. Also when i get a movie and play it or a video on Youtube it will just fade away saying “No response.” This is one of the reasons I hate Windows programming. But the orginal Windows 7 is pretty good though.

  • platelunch

    did you even read the part about DIVX? it explains the difference between DIVX and DivX.

  • DC Barnett

    The usual.
    Everybody hated DOS. Too hard. Too much to remember. Only geeks could use it. I had no problem with it. You had to read the instructions, that’s all.
    Everybody hated Windows ME. I had no problem with it. Worked great. You had to read the instructions and know where to get the drivers. Big deal.
    Everybody loved Windows NT. It sucked. Crashed constantly. I hated it. Our IT staff loved it thought because if you ever got it stable, you could lock the everliving crap out of it.
    Everybody hated Windows Vista. Still running it. Never crashed, not once. Works great.
    Got 3 machines with Windows 7 on them. Work great. No problems. Don’t know if everybody hates it or not, nor do I care. I like it fine.
    Starting to think that the problem is less than with the OS than it is with the horribly uneducated, impatient, gotta work like an appliance, ME TOO! bunch of users.

  • joshuathirteen

    Can’t see why people who just want to use a computer without getting under the hood are the problem. I’m an IT guy, 25 years. But I just want my car to work. I don’t want to know anything about the internals. I’m not uneducated or impatient because I can’t repair or maintain it myself. It’s foolish to think millions of people who don’t love computers the way we do should have to know more than how to operate it correctly and efficiently. Operation should be distinct from maintenance and repair. Nothing wrong with a good appliance that “just works”.

  • http://opinadorcompulsivo.blogspot.com Miquel Mayol i Tur

    I still use Dosbox, I have installed almost every system from MS, IBM OS2, and even DR-DOS, XP was great, but Vista/ 7 made me change into Linux(es) as main system, I have played with Linux from salckware 1991, but never as main system.

    Vista/7 sucks, at least for me, you need a lot of hardware – money – to make it run decent. Any Linux will work faster and as I used almost all open source software, Libreoffice – from it as named staroffice – thunderbird, firefox, and chrome, VLC and qbittorrent,  why suffer with the worst OS I have ever seen.

    A qemu/xen/vgapasstorught installation is what it will have, at my next computer and only as experiment.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Brian-Moore/634604260 Brian Moore

    It is called turing down your security. It is on high to being with so you don’t get a virus right away. Learn how to use a computer.

  • Roger D

    Windows Millennium.  Worst.  OS.  Ever.

    Went from that to XP and the difference was astounding.  Sure, I still had the odd problem now and then, but waaayyyy better than the non-stop crashing of WinME

  • Roger D

    And yes, that was several years ago and I have moved on to other MS “improvements”, thanks.

  • wordkyle

    Got 2 home desktops with Vista back in 2007. Still running them, no problems. I never understood the gripes.

  • Coler

    I think it is a little premature to call the iPhone 4S “upgrade” disappointing, since it hasn’t shipped yet. You might make a case for calling the iPhone “announcement” disappointing, but I think even that would be a stretch, seeing as the Apple faithful have already spoken with their wallets…and remember the original iPad reception given by the press!

    Why the rush to judge? Slow news day?

  • Like a som-boo-dee.

    I do not know why you turn me down toooday bic boy~~..
    Go fack yourshelf. That be the racist. I do not likkkkee it. I fack you tonight. Do the ban bang. VROOM VROOM FROM THE BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • http://twitter.com/rollinbishop Rollin Bishop

    Ah, see, the problem is that the perception is the reality in this case. It was a disappointment due to not being the iPhone 5. I’m not being personally critical of the iPhone 4S; I’ve got no stake in it.

    When this was written, it was talking about the public reaction–which was disappointment.

  • Coler

    I’m not sure how one gets a sense of the public “pulse”–is it from the response of “pundits”, the public comments to online news stories, the voice of one million presales buyers…I guess you just have to go with your gut and have to pick one.

  • Joel Nichols

    I’m sorry but, I find that Ubuntu’s hardware compatitibility is actually excellent. I have yet to see any modern hardware not work out of the box with it (minus graphics drivers).

    In regards to not having more installations, I’d have to agree with Miquel.

  • http://twitter.com/rollinbishop Rollin Bishop

    Yeah. It’s rough to gauge but I went with disappointment given the lapse in stock. Could have also been attributed to the major outing of Tim Cook too.