Seattle’s Lake City library has been fighting a particularly contentious fight lately, upholding patrons’ right to watch pornography on library computers. Well, not that specifically, but rather the right of patrons to access whatever content they like on the library’s unfiltered Internet content, LOLcats and porn alike. Naturally, there have been some complaints about the pornography, but things have been astoundingly civil so far.
It started when Julie Howe, at the library with her children, saw a library partron watching a little “hard-core pornography.” Howe asked him to at least move to a slightly more discreet location, but the patron refused and when Howe tried to get a librarian involved, the librarian refused as well. The library at large has stood by that librarian’s decision telling SeattlePI:
“We’re a library, so we facilitate access to constitutionally protected information. We don’t tell people what they can view and check out. Filters compromise freedom of speech protected by the First Amendment. We’re not in the business of censoring information.”
It’s worth noting that they aren’t bound to this stance. Washington State Supreme Court has actually given libraries limited and understandable filtering rights. In a 2010 decision, the court ruled that libraries have historically had some amount of control as to what they carried in their collection, and that ought to be extended to the Internet. This isn’t an order though, and Lake City library doesn’t believe in filtering, period.
The weirdest part is probably how levelheaded Howe seems to have been about the whole thing. “The man’s right to access constitutionally protected information is fully protected (which I’m not in argument with),” she said in a post on Lake City Live, a neighborhood blog, “but our right not to be inadvertent viewers is not.” A very salient and well articulated point indeed. That being said, nothing has been done to address Howe’s point so far, so you just have to watch your kids in the Lake City library if you don’t want them accidentally stumbling into some pornography.
It’s unclear how this will ultimately be resolved, or if it will be at all, but it’s refreshing to seeing the danger of censorship being treated so seriously, even in a case where the obvious solution seems to be “Just censor it! It’s porn in a public place! I mean, come on!” Still, it’s impossible to ignore the insane irony of the whole situation. I think Jessica Christensen, another patron of the library, put it best when she told SeattlePI:
“But what I find ironic is that you can’t talk too loudly at the Seattle Public Libraries or you’ll be asked to keep it down so as not to distract the other patrons. You know, the patrons viewing pornography.”
It could always be worse though, at least they’re being quiet.
- People had some issues with this couple who had sex in freefall
- With the .xxx domain rolling out, there’s plenty of porn to view at your local library
- Like peta.xxx, for example
